- 11-06-2012, 04:36 AM #1
For some reason Windows Phone fans are more fans of Nokia than the OS itself (believe me I've read posts of people wishing failure on HTC and Samsung). When the first 8X reviews came out they were very positive but most reactions were of the "that's nice but the 920 will blow it out of the water" type.
Now some 920 reviews are out and they're also fairly positive but the general feeling I get from tech bloggers is that the 8X is overall the better phone.
Obviously from a WP fanboy this is seen as a will to see Nokia/MS/WP fail but really, this is the genuine feeling I get from these people who are more in the know than us (how many of us have used these phones?).
Recently I've seen even MS evangelists expressing that feeling too: Tom Warren, Matt Miller, MJ Foley, Paul Thurrott, even our own Jay Benett called the 920 "kind of a brick" so there is definitely some truth to that.
Sure, the wireless charging and screen are nice to have but not so much that you couldn't live with the 8X. Pureview only blows away the competition in low light but is on par in other conditions so there again you could live with the 8X.
I'm curious to read Daniel's reviews because camera seems so important to him I wonder how important a factor this will be in his conclusions.
So what are your thoughts? Do you feel the 8X is really the better phone regardless of what you're actually buying (I'll probably go with the 920 for storage alone)?
PS: The postman brought me Halo 4 while I was writing this post so apologies if some bits don't make sense :)
- 11-06-2012, 05:05 AM #2
It's not about what is better, it's about one's preferences.
None of those people mentioned above can convince me that 8X is a better device cos "920 is sort of a brick". I like my phoens heavier and apart from that physicall there isnt much difference except the 920 actually has a bigger screen. The 8X is actually taller, but little thinner and little less wide, but over margins like that I rather take the extra real estate on the screen.
That said, I cheer for 8X too. I think it's important that people have choices. My choice is a 920 and I can't help but to think that at least for my needs it's easily the best WP8 device out there, but for someone with different needs I have no doubts the 8X can be a better choice.
And in all honesty, I still can't see what the 8X actually has over the 920 except for the physical dimensions and weight. If that is what makes a phone good, then I've lost faith in mankind :D
Disclaimer for above paragraph: I'm aware of certain things, like maybe the Beats audio (just a custom equalizer setting really, which 920 has customizable..) and perhaps the wide FFC if you use one (I've never used FFC yet in any of my phones) and someone might appreciate the quick consecutive photos taken by the 8X camera (Rarely a need for that for me, I value the features of the 920 camera more). But yeah, it depends on what you want and need but even as an unbiased-as-I-can statement, I can't see how anyone could broadly claim that the 8X would be a better product apart from it suiting their own needs better.
11-06-2012, 05:07 AM #4
- 4,491 Posts
I see the L920 as the better phone if you're looking for bells and whistles. It has plenty.
For many, the 8X is just more practical. Not everyone likes hefty or solidly built phones. And they're willing to trade some bells and whistles for weight reduction.
- 11-06-2012, 05:28 AM #5
11-06-2012, 05:54 AM #9
- 571 Posts
The 8X has its strong points. A dedicated amp is a nice thing to have, though I wonder how much that affects the battery life. Same goes for the wide angle FFC.
To me the 920 has more strong points. Of course all of this is dependent on what one values, and "best" will fit accordingly. Though I can't help but think the 920 tries to offer a more complete package despite its shortcomings on some practical aspects (i.e. external mem card slot, removable battery, battery capacity)
Btw as a side question, why the **** is there no gyroscope sensor on the 8X?
- Resident Developer
11-06-2012, 06:02 AM #10
- 1,073 Posts
I honestly don't know which phone I will land on, it changes every day. The wireless charging gimmick is something I do want in my life, the 32GB of storage would be a huge sign of relief over the 8X, and the power button is MUCH better positioned on the 920 than the 8X (seeing as we're talking ergonomics).
Ultimately it comes down to how important the heft of a device is to you. The 920 is a large device, it feels almost too big by today's standards and will be bulging out of all but the deepest pocket. The 8X is slender, the screen on it is comparable to the 920 less the PureMotion promise (those extra pixels on the 920 only mean that WP7 apps will scale to full screen, rather than having a small black bar) otherwise it's not a huge deal.
It's preference, some will actually prefer the 8X's camera for the post-processing which means photos will look vivid and exciting, even if they're not as true to life.
What bothers me is people who say that no one should say a bulky device is a problem, because it simply is. The Lumia is large enough to be slightly awkward to use day to day for some people. It's also going to be far more noticeable carrying it around daily, if that doesn't bother you then terrific, the 920 is certainly for you, but many people will see the 8X as a better design, even if the 16GB limit is maddening
11-06-2012, 06:19 AM #11
- 64 Posts
I chose 8X over 920 for multitude of reasons:
- I'm wary of Nokia's hardware after witnessing multitude of glitches and bugs in earlier Lumias, some of which were never fixed
- in UK Lumia 920 is locked to the most expensive mobile network (EE) and I don't want to switch or overpay for import phone from elsewhere
- in my experience HTC devices are the first to receive Windows Phone OS updates
- weight matters to me (yes, I am limp wristed, duh!)
- I don't believe Nokia's claims about the superiority of their cameras: both Lumias I've worked with had cameras clearly inferior to HTC's Titan
- I'm afraid of Nokia going under before the end of 18 months of update period of the phone, thus depriving me of WP8.5
And I'm really happy with my choice: 8X is really light but unlike older HTC devices it is also solid; the camera is great, so is the screen and the colour. The buttons are unusual but I like them - they are much better than pitiful Titan's power button.
11-06-2012, 06:38 AM #13
- 66 Posts
Great post by the OP - I have to agree, a lot of people here look a lot like Nokia fanboys (and anti- any other WP8 device). The funny thing is the 920 reviews are all very positive. They just happen to agree on one thing: for a phone with a 4.5" screen, it's oversized and heavy, which is enough to dock a point or two.
I'm getting the 8X but only because my hand has been forced (no unlocked 920s in the UK, thanks Nokia). I'll be moving from a Lumia 800. I'll see how the 8X goes and maybe pick up a 920 later. Love the 800 btw.
Reasons I'm excited about the 8X:
- Size, look, feel. I know, I know, but put a 920 in your shirt pocket and you won't want to leave it there. You might as well put a Galaxy Note in there. Phones with average screen sizes just aren't supposed to be that big and heavy. The 920 stands alone in that category. It's far from fatal for me, but it's enough to dock a point.
- Notification LED! I never see this mentioned, but if it works as it should, it's a big plus. **EDIT: no sooner do I type this than I learn the LED notification light maybe doesn't work as it should (missed calls, messages). **
- Built in amp is pretty cool. My speakers usually have to compensate for my 800's low volume. It'll be interesting to see what difference the amp makes.
So yes, I'm pretty excited to get the 8X, even though I'll miss: Nokia Drive, the touch-with-gloves screen, wireless charging and better low light shots from the camera (the top plus points for me with the 920).
Last edited by runam0k; 11-06-2012 at 06:47 AM.
11-06-2012, 06:42 AM #14
- 60 Posts
Sounds funny actually!! Lumia 920 doesn't beat other in features alone. It is about user experience where it smokes everything else out there.
Hardware front : Awesome Display, PureView Camera with OIS (Has been proven to be better than both OneX and 8X in all conditions), Rich-recoring setup, Supersensitive touchscreen. great built and premium feel, Wireless charging
Software front: Cool lenses, Great Nokia Drive apps, City Lens, Nokia Reading and many more exclusive Nokia Apps, Great customer support (software updates and more)
11-06-2012, 06:57 AM #16
- 141 Posts
great thread, OP.
This same question was bothering me from a while too.. i'd like to use pureview, supersentive touch and all the nokia exclusive apps.. but i really don't want a 180g phone in my pocket, it's kinda awkward :\
HTC 8x weights 50g less and it's smaller because of the curved backside, but still too big for me.
I think the best solution now.. is get something cheap and cool like the HTC 8S and wait for a smaller Nokia device, so i can experience the windows phone 8 OS now and always have a phone that doesn't feel like a giant brick.
.. hoping nokia will release a normal sided phone with lumia 920 exclusive features! I'd really like having that camera on my phone :(
Htc 8X and Lumia 920 compared.. still 2 giant bricks :\
But 8X is really more slim thanks to that curved backside
Last edited by AlexanderPD; 11-06-2012 at 07:02 AM. Reason: photos
- 11-06-2012, 06:58 AM #17
I would like to say yes! The HTC x is better but really we all have got to wait till we get them in hand and give it a good run don't we? After all it like buying a new car the test drive is really what sells us. The make, model, accessories, colors, handling, and other options are just as important but in the end we will have to wait for the test drive.
Last edited by pmhgeneral; 11-06-2012 at 07:10 AM.
- Resident Developer
11-06-2012, 07:30 AM #18
- 1,073 Posts
11-06-2012, 07:31 AM #19
- 196 Posts
I got the 8x due to the limitations of getting the 920 in the UK (i was not prepared to jump ship from vodafone)
I used the headphones for the 1st time this morning on my walk into work and as soon as insert headphones a little message appears on screen saying 'beats audio enabled'
The sound quality is so much better than my HTC Trophy.
11-06-2012, 07:55 AM #21
- 162 Posts
HTC 8x doesn't offer anything extra compared to Lumia 920. Internal amp maybe but where do you need it? Really need it?
Point being, if you want lighter and somewhat physically more comfortable phone, buy 8X. Otherwise Lumia 920. Of course availability and that stuff is different story.
I chose Lumia 920 because:
- Nokia is 100% dedicated to WP. It means rapid responses to bugs, it means nice exclusive apps and so on. They need to excel the expectations and for example with Lumia 900 early wifi problems, they really took agressive approach addressing the problem.
- Camera is good in low light (the most important thing I would say, because almost all cameras today takes decent day-time shots).
- I take videos and too often in loud places (bars and stuff) so rich recording is killer feature
- including OIS to videos => superb I would say
- I like the design. Its timeless. Weight is no issue, why would it be? Only a bit downsize is the size. I would've preferred 4" screen.
- Display. Undisputed champion. Most important for me is CBD for outside use and ability to use it with gloves. But all in all, it doesn't matter what features you like, this display has it
- Navigation. I don't know if the drive+ app is for all wp phones? But with Lumia920 you can be sure the have the best nav
- 32gb out of the box is good. If only 16gb, I would have doubts.
- I like colors, took yellow (8x has also so no decision factor)
- last but not least, I really like to have that wireless charging pillow next to my bed. Always in mornings battery is full. Another place where I might buy one is next to my keyboard at work. People say that plugging the cord to phone is no biggie, but it is because you need remember to plug it.
So, now I am just waiting my yellow Lumia 920 to arrive.
11-06-2012, 09:41 AM #25
- 25 Posts
I will be curious when wireless charging is included in the Verizon 8X what kind of weight it adds.
On your last point I think HTC is in more trouble than Nokia at this point. Nokia keeps bleeding money but has other divisions to help while HTC has none of that.
With all that being said I do hope HTC pulls it together and hope the 8X is a hit. We need choices and so far its only Nokia and HTC really providing them.