01-06-2013, 12:33 PM #26
- 89 Posts
I like this a lot. I think if MS were to add a charm bar similar to yours it would be really useful. Especially for settings (wifi and data toggles). I like it!
I would also like to say that I don't like the connectivity or battery info in the second design. It takes away from the clean look of the first design.
Also, sorry if I missed it. How would you access the charms bar? Is it a simple swipe gesture or by using the physical windows button? A mixture of both or is the charms bar always there? Another thing, what about the lock screen? I think the physical Windows button could play a roll in this by accessing the charms bar while on the lock screen? Again, I like the idea of the charms bar. Oh and I think having a charms bar would be better off hidden too ( swipe or physical button to access).
Last edited by deansmilk; 01-06-2013 at 12:57 PM.
- 01-06-2013, 12:48 PM #27
- 01-06-2013, 01:34 PM #29
- 01-06-2013, 02:06 PM #31
This is my first attempt, so go easy.
I have trieds to include the things that I think would be most useful. Same as Linking, I had thought of using the wording as a direct link to the specific location.
I also borrowed the charms idea but added this at the bottom.
My next ideas are to add more into the above screen, such as notifications and running apps, with the option to close them. I reckon there is room.
Last edited by peachy001; 01-06-2013 at 04:14 PM.
- 01-06-2013, 02:28 PM #32
I am really happy that you were able to pull this off, I know that if each one of us did a small effort in trying to improve the OS he loves then its going to happen eventually.
I like the idea that you brought to the table, to use something that already exists on WP 8 machines, but I still can't see MS implementing this using volume controls, they are finding a hard time explaining some of the things they use in their OS, they even placed the right arrow at the bottom of the tiles so users are not confused and can find the app list!
don't you think that this can be grouped better and better understood for users using the charms bar only? esp people that use Windows 8 already and have a clue about how it works.
Nevertheless, I really find any of these implementations made it to WP, eventually it's us that get the best benifit out of everything. P.S: I am not sorry for your girlfriend =P. This totally worths it!
01-06-2013, 02:39 PM #33
- 16 Posts
I really Like the first design, Its very elegant and clean.
And i dont think a drop down menu from the top would be a bad thing, granted I know iOS and Andriod do it that way, BUT Its what everyone is already used to if there coming from another Mobile OS, its kinda become a natural movment at this point. Though I am still in favor with something to the left side of the screen.
BUT, If MS would go with something like the first example, It Still would be a way different experience from what you see from iOS and Andriod. Something like the charms seems so much more....Simple and would flow a lot better, and with something like the above exampe, it would almost seem that you could squeeze more options and menu's in. Plus I like that close app feature that you put in there.
Either way nice designs!
01-06-2013, 02:55 PM #35
- 613 Posts
I like the OP's second design with a slight change. In windows 8 to close an open app you do a slow pull, then faster to drag it to the bottom of the screen. Lets combine the OP's first and second idea, a quick swipe from the top will show your battery level, signal strength 4g/lte and wifi status, dragging a bit further would then bring the charms bar down. or the charms bar takes the left of the screen when swiping in. Closing apps can be left to the long press on the back button and then flicking the app down to close. Replacing existing functionality should be avoided, and using the volume rocker could be considered difficult for new users to figure out without having to read an instruction paper. Most would look at it and think there was one function to a physical button, and would never figure out long presses on these buttons.
01-06-2013, 03:09 PM #36
- 4,482 Posts
I love what I'm seeing here.
It would be pretty great to have more consistency when moving from Windows 8 and Windows Phone and back. So these ideas are definitely the foundation for something awesome.
I imagine (hope) that something similar is already in the works with Microsoft. WP8 and W8 working well together is going to be big for their future.
- 01-06-2013, 04:43 PM #39
Actually I really liek the idea! After using my Surface, I find myself trying to use many of the same swipe commands on my L920 and it makes me wonder why WP8 and W8 have been designed so differently.
It doesnt have to be the same charms as on W8 (although sorta no reason why not), but those "swipes from the outside" should definitely be utilized IMO. For example that notification center and some quick settings.
01-06-2013, 05:04 PM #40
- 308 Posts
Sorry if this was mentioned already as I didn't read all the posts.. But I read somewhere an idea someone had for swiping in a left menu for notification center.. Since you have start and swipe right and get the "all apps" page.
[notications] [start] [all apps]
that sort of format.. I really liked that idea and perhaps doing something like that and merging it with some of the stuff you pointed out there.. swipe right and you get a menu of popular settings and notifications... I like the concept of the buttons at the top and then instead of a series of drop down menus of sorts, change the page below.. I think that would be cool..
though I really do like the concept are you showed here.. I hope MS sees them.
- 01-06-2013, 05:24 PM #41
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. =)
- 01-06-2013, 05:41 PM #42
My second attempt.
This time I have added the extra notification bits below the original quick toggle selection. The quick toggles are there so that there is no need to dive in to the settings menu. Many times while at work or other occaissions, I need to be able to quickly do one of those toggle items.
The bottom half is an at a glance of 3 areas. I wanted notifications to always be central but you can of course swipe left or right and go to either apps or tasks.
I have changed the charms. I have tried to incorporate a few different features. Following on from a comment above, I have swapped the "Start" one to now be a close/remove tool. This is used to drag a selected item(s) and remove them.
This is not designed to replace the notification centre, which I think should be a swipe away on left from the main screen. I may put together a larger one and mock up that screen if I have time. Mine is based around the volume buttons or (thanks for the suggestion) a long press on one of the capacitve buttons.
Sorry for the colour too, it is a bit harsh on the eyes and not as paletable as the light blue that Linking' used, but I started in that colour so carried on.
The items at the bottom are: Search, Select, Close/remove, Notifications, Settings.
All comments very welcome.
Last edited by peachy001; 01-06-2013 at 06:07 PM.
- 01-07-2013, 06:18 AM #49
Not got the time on mine, but I added call forwarding and alarm, may take them off. Regarding the notification size, This can be altered.
It was an idea I had before, it is not designed to replace a left move from the home screen as far as notifications goes. I have not got a Windows 8 PC, so I had not seen the charms before. I have altered the ones linking included, as these ones work for me better and have common phone icons.
- 01-07-2013, 09:52 AM #50
Believe me, thr charms bar is the best thing that happened to Windows since Windows! It's really refreshing and it makes life easier. You have to try minipulating them to get a better understanding of why I think their implementation must be a necessity in WP!
I saw what other modifications you did to your design, I like the additions they bring, really.
- By thecaringkind in forum Nokia Lumia 900Replies: 41Last Post: 08-14-2012, 12:31 PM
- By diplomat696 in forum Windows Phone AppsReplies: 2Last Post: 08-07-2012, 06:24 PM
- By gedmurphy in forum Windows Phone 8Replies: 21Last Post: 07-01-2012, 08:18 AM
- By CamiKitti in forum HTC SurroundReplies: 1Last Post: 11-21-2011, 01:00 PM
- By danygandhi in forum HTC TITANReplies: 8Last Post: 11-15-2011, 04:05 PM