- 12-12-2013, 06:40 PM #1
Do you have the same problem? Try this: Plugin earphones, watch a video on youtube then pause the video. I hear some kind of swoosh sound...when i close the youtube tab the sound is gone but then it comes back randomly and stops again.
Im using perfectly fine earphones from apple which work great with other devices.
edit: its like the fan noise coming through the earbuds ...weird
edit2: the swoosh sound is completely gone when i mute the sound
- 12-12-2013, 09:46 PM #2
Maybe you hear your avatar screaming?
Lol, on a different try a different earphone to see if there is any difference so you know that your different earphone reacts differently with your same phone while your same earphone reacts differently with your same phone, phew!
- 12-15-2013, 10:16 AM #12
To answer your question;
I have both the first generation surface RT and the new Surface Pro 2.
Both of my devices have the scratching sound when earphone are connected through the minijack port and a video I paused. If no playback audio is running in the background, ae not running a video or having a music program open, then there won't be any sound, but as soon as I am playing an audio file, even when paused, then the scratching sound re-appears. It also present while the video is playing, although it is too feint to really hear over the sound of anything actually playing. I know it is not my earphones being broken as I use them with my phone and desktop as well. The issue does lie with the surface's mini jack input, as there is no scratching sound when using an USB headphone set. I cannot tell You why it is happening, only that it is caused by the mini jack input.
- 12-15-2013, 07:29 PM #16
I don't get the issue, this is normal for onboard sound solution. The audio chip used is AT MOST 2$... and can reach 5-10$ on ultra high-end desktop computer motherboard. The sound quality simply sucks. If you want rich quality sound that pushes the full potential of your headphones, and be able to drive high impedance headphones, with no static or distortion, you need to cash out on a dedicated sound card.
On my desktop, I have the ASUS Xonar Essence STX on PCI-E, a 200$ sound card. This is nothing pro grade. Sounds cards are expensive, because components to give you proper clean sound are costly, more over, it's not something you actually change. you keep it until it breaks. It usually last 2-3 computer builds on my side... so 8-10 years life cycle.. and even then it's more it doesn't support the latest version of Windows, or I seek for better sound card. So not bad investment. Now, of course, I know the Surface Pro device can't be open and inserted a PCI-E card. But they are USB sound card for about 70-100$ which are pretty good, and fairly small.
If you are on a tight budget, you have the ASUS Xonar U3 for 30-35$. It's not going to give you some amazing sound, but it will give you a sound that maybe better than what you have (I don't have a SP2 yet to compare, sold out everywhere), but it will give you a nice clean sound, almost static free... well the best a 35$ can get you.
The reason why you have the sound only when you pause the video, is because on mobile devices, the sound card "turns-off" when not being in used to save power.
If you wonder:
-> My laptop onboard sounds like I am using dollar shop earphone, despite costly ones. It has no base, and no mid range.
-> My desktop onboard sound has static, and everything sounds like my speakers on inside a metal barrel.
-> My old desktop onboard sound has heavy static, and sounded like I am having the Transformers do the music.
On board sound card are designed to offer you basic sound, for basic video watching, and Windows sounds. Not give you this rich, live like experience. They are designed to be virtually free. It has no SPU (Sound Processing Unit), it just takes the sound, simplifies it, send it to the CPU for processing, get it back and converted using the cheapest component possible from digital to analogue.
- 12-16-2013, 10:34 AM #18
Money isn't invested in sound quality, because as you can see from the manufactures of sound card, it's a niche market. People don't care about sound quality.
You have 2 companies at the consumer level: Creative Labs that is barely surviving, and cant' afford developers for half decent drivers, and then you have ASUS which makes great product and good drivers, where their audio department is not making any profit, nothing significant at least, but do it because they want to, for the gamer that cares, and audio enthusiasts.
If you want manufactures to change this, then you need to demand it. Meaning: Start buying dedicated sound card, show to manufacture that there is actually a market for quality sound, and that people care, and then you'll get them, to put a higher grade sound solution and better components to output, as a result, better sound. It must be noted as well, that, and this is something I forgot to mentioned, is that those cheap-*** onboard sound card have 1 big strength over a proper sound solution: significant reduction of power usage.
My dedicated sound card, for example, requires, much like my graphic card, a dedicated power to power the card for additional power, and it is true that using a USB sound card will draw more power and visibly reduce the system battery life.
- 02-06-2014, 11:12 PM #21
Usually, it's because of improper assembly of internal parts of a computer device, a headphone's audio jack may lie too close to a motherboard, hence the motherboard might interfere with the audio channel and cause this permanent static noise: .
02-07-2014, 02:02 PM #22
- 3 Posts
Seems like there is a mixed response in this thread, where some users have this issue while others don't. Is this really a hardware defect? I don't want to go through the trouble of exchanging my device to receive another one that also has this issue.
- 02-07-2014, 03:13 PM #23
That's the thing. it depends.
If it's loud static, then it's defect.
If it's a small hissing, than that's the onboard sound solution, and there is no fix, until manufactures uses dedicated sound card.
OnBoard sound chip:
The above is essentially the entire thing that processes and output the sound.
Dedicated sound card:
View of a dedicated sound card without the Electromagnetic shielding plate
As you can see, a dedicated sound card has a lot more components, and of much higher quality to process, convert from digital to analogue, and amplify the sound.
Many of them has even, dedicated power, like the one above, which is used to get a nice clean power and ground from your power supply, and use a common ground. In addition, the analogue area of the sound card is shielded against interference that occurs inside your system, and wireless devices.
If you want good, clear, lively, vivid, crisp sound, that is what you need.
Else you get what you get with the Surface Pro, or any other consumer computer with onboard sound solution: flat, mundane, lack of any med-range signal, staticky, can't drive any high impedance headphone, and prone to hear interference with the system.
You don't need 300$ headphones to enjoy the sound of a dedicated sound card. You should hear a noticeable difference (assuming your music is in high quality) with 30-50$ headphones.
Of course, the dedicated sound card above is a bit far fetch, but it's just to give an example of what is available on the market as internal sound card. You can imagine lower end card with less fancy component and no electromagnetic shielding plate.
As long as the consumer is content with onboard solution, don't expect any change. The reason why manufacture uses onboard sound card, is because they are 1-2$
If you look at Amazon.com, you can find them at <5$, and those are with USB adapter, and of course have to assume some profit. So having just the chip... yup, cheap.
The dedicated sound card above is around 200$. But they are decent ones at 50-70$ which still massacre onboard sound solutions.
02-07-2014, 03:47 PM #24
- 3 Posts
Thanks for the reply MBytes, I really appreciate your detailed explanation.
From your explanation I understand I shouldn't expect high quality sound from the onboard sound solution of my SP2. I tried using the same earphones with my laptop and phone again. On the laptop I hear the same hissing static noise, its just extremely quiet and not noticeable. On my phone (Galaxy S2) it's a bit louder, but easy to ignore. On my SP2 however, it's difficult to ignore to the point that it bothers me.
I think in my case, though such noise is expected for an onboard solution, is more extreme. How is it with your SP2? What I'm wondering is how it turned out for the OP with his new exchanged SP2.
- 02-07-2014, 04:05 PM #25
I hear hissing. But it is about the same as my laptop. I don't have a smartphone to try and compare. My laptop onboard sound is from IDT.
The sound quality is however, superior on my SP2. Not that it means anything... because the sound that my laptop comes out through any headphone I plug to it, sounds like the music is being played in a metal barrel. And no it's not faulty... I pass through 3 of them. A friend of mine had got the same laptop as me, and he was happy with the sound... however, when I hear it from his own headphones on his system, I hear the same of what I hear l mine. So I guess it depends on your standards.
You could try at the store the headphone. Bring a music file on you in a USB key.. however, I guess you'll have or come in a time where the store is quiet, and I know its hard in a big retail store.
If it really bugs you, well replace your system. But if you are out of the return period, and you don't have a Microsoft store close by, then I think it will be a bad move, as you'll most likely get a refurbished. Shame for a new unit. if you want, I guess you can plug your SP2 on your best PC you have line in jack (or mic if no choice, but be sure to not have the mic boost on, as this will make things worst), and record a segment in high quality mp3, and be sure it sounds the same level as the surface pro 2, and send that to me. I
ll play it on my desktop, which has a dedicated sound card, ans I can compare. It's not great solution, as my volume level could make my test less or worse than you actually have. But if its anything drastic, it should be noticeable I think.
- By HeyCori in forum Microsoft Surface 2Replies: 5Last Post: 04-08-2014, 01:52 AM
- By RJ Priest in forum Xbox Console GamingReplies: 10Last Post: 12-16-2013, 08:54 AM
- By taimur_3 in forum Nokia Lumia 820Replies: 4Last Post: 12-12-2013, 11:21 PM
- By DHHSMichael in forum Windows Phone 8Replies: 27Last Post: 12-12-2013, 07:42 PM
- By Nikos Krhtsotakhs in forum Nokia Lumia 520Replies: 1Last Post: 12-12-2013, 04:34 PM