- 09-14-2012, 12:46 AM #3
Of course I'm happy if the Lumia 920 comes away looking better, but this is precisely one of those puff pieces I was talking about here. The author is comparing the two phones based on paper spec-sheets and his imagination. He talks about screen resolutions (because it's on the sheet), but mentions nothing about readability in sunlight, color reproduction, responsiveness or usability (with gloves). He mentions battery size, but nothing about how long you can actually surf or talk with them... etc, etc, etc. He is doing everyone who reads his "review" a disservice, by implying it's sensible to base purchasing decisions on spec-sheets.
Reviewers like him should be boo'd into oblivion. But, thanks for the link anyway. Doesn't hurt to know what is out there.
- 09-14-2012, 12:49 AM #4Nokia Lumia 900 - OS: 7.10.8112.7 - Firmware: 2175.1002.8112.12084
HTC Surround - OS: 7.10.8107.79 - Firmware: 2250.21.40500.502
- 09-14-2012, 01:46 AM #5
Even Apple's ecosystem is better for now. Microsoft's not there yet but it looks, oh, so promising. I really hope Microsoft will succeed in their vision of seamless integration between devices and I love the new bold direction they're taking of leading the pack.
Give it a year and the Microsoft ecosystem will be a SERIOUS contender. Two years and the mainstream will get tired of Apple. 3 years and it will be time to think about selling those Apple shares and lamenting about the fact you never bought any from Nokia. :P
- 09-14-2012, 01:50 AM #6
Unfortunately, yes, comparing specs on paper is the only way to compare these two phones right now. Despite how much they may tout their new features, a real comparison can only be made once you can lay them both side by side and make a subjective observation.
09-14-2012, 02:34 AM #8
- 266 Posts
Good point, but a true comparison can only be made one we have the phones side by side AND Win8 released and out in the wild. Im beginning to sound like an evangelist here, but I believe the single biggest advantage WP8 has will be its integration with the cloud/desktop/surface devices. That is massive, and the whole reason I am switching, to a certain extent, as long as the hardware is capable it isn't really that important and becomes a personal choice...
The integration is a unique selling point, and hopefully will change the way we do things..
There are alot of people out there, me included who know that WP7.xx was a well designed OS but would never consider it as the benefits weren't there, now with Win 8 and WP8, they are and alot of people are waking upto the idea of switching
- 09-14-2012, 03:09 AM #9
What I'm criticizing is the fact that these spec-sheet-gurus end up making purchasing recommendations based on them. That I find despicable.
I'm guessing these spec-sheet-guru's need to complete these write-ups ASAP, so they don't have the time to go beyond simple spec-sheet numbers even if they wanted to. As a result, thousands of people out there, currently trying to find out exactly what the Lumia 920 is, won't get even half of the story.
Lack of any meaningful analysis is one issue:
Going by the spec-sheet, the Lumia 920 has a weight of 185g. Ouch! That will be put down as a negative. But shouldn't they also be asking themselves where that weight comes from? Every engineering decision is a trade-off, meaning that weight comes from something that Nokia thought was worthwhile. Could it be that Lumias are built like tanks in comparison to competing devices? Could it be that Lumias aren't intended to be carried in a protective cover? Well yes. However, add a protective cover to an iPhone, which is common practice, and you end up with a device which is equally thick and heavy but a whole lot uglier.
The other main issue is that a lot of important features just can't be expressed via a spec-sheet. For Nokia and Microsoft this is particularly important because most people aren't familiar with WP. So, because so many people think specs are all this is about, many people won't hear about:
- the WP UI being person-focused instead of app-focused
- the best offline pedestrian and car navigation solution with Navteqs industry leading mapping-data.
- the best augmented reality navigational aid
- what you can actually use NFC for (how many of those spec-sheet comparisons mention Nokia's NFC capable accessories)
- etc etc etc
I'm not against spec-comparisons per se (although I find the limited high-level spec-sheets we normally see only marginally useful), but it needs to be stated more clearly that WP8 is so different from Android and iOS, that you need to go beyond the spec-sheet to understand what's so unique and great about it.
Last edited by a5cent; 09-14-2012 at 07:17 AM. Reason: Total rewrite. Sorry.
- 09-14-2012, 05:33 AM #11
09-14-2012, 06:20 AM #12
- 266 Posts
edit - I should qualify that statement - I work in IT :)
09-14-2012, 06:37 AM #13
- 1,032 Posts
Touche about the Microsoft services. People love them once they get exposure to them.
Moving to universal connectors like micro-USB might be a bit more appealing now.
- 09-14-2012, 07:40 AM #14
Well, for all that it is worth, I for one would really appreciate an ecosystem - including the device and services - which is not so heavily reliant on the cloud/wifi/online services.
There are a lot of us who live and work in places and countries where there is very limited to no wifi access and or our service providers think that 256mb a month is ample for our online needs. That is one of the reasons why my Lumia and Touchpad gather dust 6 out 7 days of the week.
- 09-14-2012, 09:46 AM #15
Regarding the iOS accessory advantage, that's the tradeoff for selling a single device with a single footprint. How many Android accessories are out there? Even for the ever popular Samsung Galaxy series.
Now with wireless charging, NFC and BT, docks will be as simple as adding a ledge to prop your phone against. But because of the many different WP form factors, which is a good thing, don't expect to ever see a rack full of custom cases for your favorite device. I'm ok with that.
Sent from my Lumia 900 using Board Express ProNokia Lumia 900 - OS: 7.10.8112.7 - Firmware: 2175.1002.8112.12084
HTC Surround - OS: 7.10.8107.79 - Firmware: 2250.21.40500.502
- 09-14-2012, 09:54 AM #16
All things considered, there has never been a better opportunity for WP to gain traction. Many people are currently very disappointed in the new iteration of Apple's iphone. Many people skipped the 4s in hopes of 5. Many tech sites are reporting on the lack of excitement around the new product.
Nokia has, in the meantime, released a truly innovative device that tackles and bests Apple's new offering. True, the die-hard fans will flock to the new iphone, but many others have been betting on the new iphone. And these people are now very disappointed.
What's more, the Lumia 920 is now getting free publicity because everyone is comparing the iphone to it. Every tech site. This is great news. For once, we might just be at the cusp of something truly revolutionary. It helps too that when placed side by side, the 920 simply draws all the attention.
Also, Android fans in a bit to clamp down on Apple fanboys are heavily backing the 920, if Youtube videos are anything to go by. We should also remember that only a few years ago Nokia reigned supreme. Many of today's smartphone users have used a Nokia once. There's some sentimental value attached with any Nokia device.
On a related topic, people are already referring to the Cinemagraph lens as the Harry Potter app. Moving pictures indeed, this is magic. Nokia FTW
- 09-14-2012, 11:30 AM #20
Last edited by inteller; 09-14-2012 at 11:36 AM.
- 09-14-2012, 12:18 PM #22
Microsoft has specified that the USB connector must be exactly centered on the bottom of every WP8 phone. So, no matter what device you buy, your USB connector will be in the same spot. The reasoning behind this move was precisely to allow 3rd parties to build standardized accessories that work with each and every WP8 phone, even if you're using the USB cable. Rejoice! ;)
- 09-14-2012, 02:11 PM #23
I don't know if I buy into the whole ecosystem idea or not. I think "the ecosystem" is an interesting word because it means a million different things to a million different people. Does it refer to the apps? Hardware accessories? Does it only refer to the online services belonging to the OS developer (iTunes for iOS or Zune Music for WP) or does the ecosystem include every single online service the device can access (including sites like Amazon with the Kindle app). Does the ecosystem include enterprise services that users employers might have created? Is "the ecosystem" any of these technical things at all, or is it perhaps something less technical like an investment, which could mean a monetary investment (all the paid-for apps) or an investment in time (the time it took to learn to use the OS efficiently). Is it all of the above, parts of it, or something else entirely? I would be surprised if we all had the same definition of the term. I think the answer to the ecosystem question varies depending on what we think it means. If anybody knows what "the ecosystem" really is, I would be glad to learn about it.