01-16-2013 06:39 PM
26 12
tools
  1. robstunner's Avatar
    Hello,

    out with the old and in with the new i suppose, I just thought i would post my findings and see what everyone thought. My One X is using Sense 4.5 camera mod, and I have always been very pleased wit the photos it had. Below are 5 pictures of the same stuff. All auto focus, all 4:3 ratio with no touching up of the photo other than photo-buckets automatic re-sizing.

    First and foremost, this isn't a troll post, just merely sharing my findings:

















    So, which do you think are the Lumia, and which are the One X?
    11-15-2012 03:55 PM
  2. rmichael75's Avatar
    Hello,

    out with the old and in with the new i suppose, I just thought i would post my findings and see what everyone thought. My One X is using Sense 4.5 camera mod, and I have always been very pleased wit the photos it had. Below are 5 pictures of the same stuff. All auto focus, all 4:3 ratio with no touching up of the photo other than photo-buckets automatic re-sizing.

    First and foremost, this isn't a troll post, just merely sharing my findings:

    Click to view quoted image

    Click to view quoted image


    Click to view quoted image

    Click to view quoted image


    Click to view quoted image

    Click to view quoted image


    Click to view quoted image

    Click to view quoted image


    Click to view quoted image

    Click to view quoted image



    So, which do you think are the Lumia, and which are the One X?
    the clearer ones (2nd ones) as it has the slight yellow tint.

    Am I correct?.
    11-15-2012 04:02 PM
  3. robstunner's Avatar
    The second ones are more yellow, or the first ones?
    11-15-2012 04:03 PM
  4. euchrid_eucrow's Avatar
    My guess, in order from top to bottom; the HTC is the Top image in the: 1st, 2nd, 4th, and the HTC is the bottom image in the 3rd and 5th(last) comparisons.
    11-15-2012 04:12 PM
  5. robstunner's Avatar
    :) Ill wait for a few more comments
    11-15-2012 04:13 PM
  6. wamsille's Avatar
    The first one is Foldgers. I think the third from the bottom is Maxwell House.

    I have an idea, as I owned both the HTC One X and now I own the Lumia 920. This is a very subjective test though.
    11-15-2012 04:24 PM
  7. robstunner's Avatar
    All the first one's are HTC

    Sent from my RM-820_nam_att_100 using Board Express
    11-15-2012 04:27 PM
  8. wamsille's Avatar
    The tell in the first pair is the muted paint color on the wall (photo # 2).
    11-15-2012 04:32 PM
  9. gwip's Avatar
    The bottom of each group would be my guess for the 920. Regardless, I think the bottom images look best. Much better dynamic range and overall exposure. Take a look at the bright spots and you can see which ever camera is taking the images on the bottom handles highlights so much better. There's just so much more detail there. It's best illustrated in the skyline of the 4th group.
    11-15-2012 04:37 PM
  10. LazyLemming's Avatar
    L920 on the bottom. #1 and #2 you can see the Lumia is just ever so slightly softer with more muted colors. The HTC is a bit more saturated. The colors for the Lumia also appear a bit more realistic.

    #3 the HTC didn't or wasn't able to focus correctly on the bottle.

    #4 Again just slightly softer but with more muted coloring.

    #5 would be pretty hard to tell but the Lumia is just a little brighter throughout the photo.
    11-15-2012 04:50 PM
  11. robstunner's Avatar
    I think I actually prefer the sharper images of the One X vs the color correction of the Lumia :-/
    11-15-2012 05:22 PM
  12. euchrid_eucrow's Avatar
    Same here, the HTCs also look nicer to my eye. What threw me off was the glass cleaner and remote pics because of how sharp they were. What i forgot is that the lumia is pretty good in macro. The softness of daylight photos on the lumia is a real bummer for me esp. since the camera had been hyped so much. I'm convinced that its all heavy noise reduction/processing in order to make the night shots so spectacular. Its a shame you just can't turn off NR on it or that we can't access the raw file.
    11-15-2012 05:36 PM
  13. robstunner's Avatar
    Agreed, doesnt help when you order the phone online for mail delivery and its a 14 day return policy.
    11-17-2012 09:18 AM
  14. Jaripi's Avatar
    Should see the original photos ... did you use 16:9 or 4:3 setting for Lumia 920 photos ?
    11-17-2012 10:13 AM
  15. robstunner's Avatar
    Should see the original photos ... did you use 16:9 or 4:3 setting for Lumia 920 photos ?
    read the OP. 4:3 on all photos, both devices.
    11-17-2012 10:15 AM
  16. robstunner's Avatar
    two more:

    It seems like any time you zoom in on a photo, you can easily tell that its much more grainy.

    HTC:


    Nokia:
    11-23-2012 05:42 PM
  17. 12Danny123's Avatar
    awww. you're dog's got the cute doggy eyes. My puppy does that all the time. I can't resist it :-).


    on topic: those are good pics from Nokia. good job Nokia.....I mean your phone of course
    11-23-2012 05:52 PM
  18. Pete C's Avatar
    robstunner, go into a wooded area when the sun is out and take pics of the trees. I have found the One X to bleed light like crazy. I don't know what the issue is, but in broad daylight the light leaks and ends up looking like a hazy filter on the picture.
    11-23-2012 08:09 PM
  19. robstunner's Avatar
    robstunner, go into a wooded area when the sun is out and take pics of the trees. I have found the One X to bleed light like crazy. I don't know what the issue is, but in broad daylight the light leaks and ends up looking like a hazy filter on the picture.
    Hmm, ill try. I do know from past experiences that the one x over saturates colors in the photos.
    11-23-2012 08:10 PM
  20. Levir3's Avatar
    Hi,
    Were the Lumia pictures taken before or after the lumia-firmware update?
    This should remove the "softness" that so many people complain about.
    If the pictures were taken before it would be interesting to see how they come out after the upgrade.
    Rgrds,
    Leo
    01-11-2013 06:23 AM
  21. Levir3's Avatar
    Hi,
    Were the Lumia pictures taken before or after the firmware upgrade that supposes to remove the "softness" in day light pictures?
    If before it would be interesting to see how they come out after the upgrade.
    I'm hesitating between Htc one x plus and the Lumia 920. Photo quality is decisive for me.
    Rgrds,
    Leo
    01-11-2013 06:27 AM
  22. Pete C's Avatar
    The HTC One X is still sharper even after the update. I posted 2 shots below which illustrate both phones in Auto mode. The Lumia shot is post-update. It is a well lit nightstand and the difference in detail is fairly obvious. However, the One X is still noisier. The One X is always noisier/grainier and that is really the most noticeable flaw of that camera...especially when shooting people. It is also terrible in low light. The Lumia's main flaw IMO is that it has **** poor automatic white balance. You are constantly getting greenish shots like the one below. To compensate I will often select Fluorescent in the white balance menu to get a warmer shot.

    The One X's forte is shooting stationary objects in good lighting. I have had major difficulty with the One X focusing on a relatively close moving object, such as a child. It is hard to get a good lock, and using the burst mode degrades the quality considerably. Taking single shots I end up with a few excellent photos mixed in with a bunch of blurry, unfocused shots. The Lumia 920 focus is excellent by comparison. Seriously, I never have a focus problem.

    In low light the difference is magnified due to the lack of OIS on the One X. Minor hand motions blur the shot so you have to be absolutely still to get a good one. OIS on the Lumia eliminates this problem almost every time. If the object is moving you will still have motion blur on either phone.

    Another advantage to the Lumia is just the mechanical advantage of having the shutter button. I can focus on the subject then wait for the shot I want, then fully depress the key to take the shot quickly. Or you have the option to single press to focus and take the shot. The One X you have to tap to focus, then tap another icon to take the shot. It is almost impossible to use effectively with one hand, especially without introducing hand shake blur.

    Note: above I mentioned the hazy/light bleeding appearance of the HTC One X outside. Well, afterward I noticed that had been shooting with a oily lens. I have found since that the One X is EXTREMELY sensitive to any sort of smudges or oils on the lens. It must be perfectly clean. The Lumia is a bit more forgiving in this regard.


    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	Nokia Lumia 920.jpg 
Views:	15 
Size:	639.5 KB 
ID:	26652Click image for larger version. 

Name:	HTC One X.jpg 
Views:	19 
Size:	815.4 KB 
ID:	26649
    Last edited by Pete C; 01-11-2013 at 11:57 AM.
    hyedefinition likes this.
    01-11-2013 08:55 AM
  23. Levir3's Avatar
    Thanks for this elaborate reply (and white balance tip) Pete.
    I've decided to go for the Lumia.
    Rgrds,
    Leo
    01-12-2013 04:05 AM
  24. wangvnn's Avatar
    Guys I already explained this before. We need the good lens to take good picture. Nokia only talks about the floating len for low light and video. The iphone has 5 layers len which can take brighter shaper picture, same for htc or samsung galaxy s3. The lumia even does apply denoise proccessing to make the lowlight picture look awesome, but it kills the details for other cases. So dont give too much hope for the new firmware up unless it can change the hardware. Indeed lumia 920 still is the BEST ALL ROUNDED CAMERA PHONE
    01-12-2013 08:00 AM
  25. antsin3d's Avatar
    In that last example, I vastly prefer the white balance on the 920. With that said, I find a lot of the shots posted from the Lumia to be too high in contrast and off in white balance.
    01-12-2013 09:01 AM
26 12
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD
";