- 11-18-2012, 10:00 AM #1
OK, no trolling here:
Just wanted to hear from people who decided to leave windows phone 8 and the lumia. Did you go back to apple/android? Or another windows phone 8 device? What was the tipping point in your decision and why did you ultimately go back to your previous device?
Personally, I still haven't made up my mind yet. There's a few apps that are missing that I'd like to use (like my bank app) but its not a big deal since I have my nexus 7 which I absolutely enjoy to use now that 4.2 is out. The lumia is noticeably smoother than my one x and my one x is rooted with a custom ROM and all that de/lagging stuff. I think my personal biggest reason to want to stay with the lumia is my crack head flash friendly time waisting lust towards new Roms and setups. After a few years of dealing with debloating, rooting, unlocking and going into every app to shut off power drainers like "automatic checking in via GPS" and stupid push notifications its really a relief to just use the phone, as a phone. Perhaps what makes it even better is that my nexus 7 is still around if I feel like messing with Roms.
I wish Nokia had more accessories that actually matter, like a nice car dock.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
- 11-18-2012, 11:04 AM #4
this is a great question and one that I am debating right now as I have my GS3 sitting next to my 920. I use CM10 on my GS3 as my daily driver ROM and while it is pretty stable, the battery life leaves much to be desired. Let me say first that I really like WP. The OS is designed as a phone first while Android is kind of a computer OS running on a phone. But there are functions in WP that are missing and Im not just taking about the apps. You cant reject a call with a SMS? You cant take a picture while filming a video? These are small things that I use frequently, that just dont exist in WP, or I havent been able to find them. It also takes many more steps to do certain tasks. Like launching a web site from favorites in a new tab. If I have got this right, you have to hit settings, then hit tabs, then hit the plus symbol then back to settings, back to favorites and then launch. Compare this to Android. Press the tabs button, press bookmarks, long press on the page you want to launch an select open in new tab. Thats a three step process as compared to 5. WP cold alleviate by giving you the option when you long press the favorite you want to launch, but you only get two options, edit and delete. This is one example but this lack of depth is visible throughout the OS. I also think the phone is too big. Its not that it hurts my arm or anything but it creates a noticeable bulge in my jean pocket and it weighs down my pant pockets in a big way. The phone is almost the exact same size as my GS3 but the screen is visibly smaller. It just seems like you dont get all the benefit from the size of the phone.
On the plus size, the email client is so far superior to Android its not even funny. Its actually the best email client I have every used, better than IOS as well. Being able to swipe right on time to get unread is so awesome it cant be understated. I still haven't figured out a way to sort my email by unread on Android. This is a feature I use all the time. I also really like the people hub. What a great way to keep up on the friends you want to keep up on. Battery life for me has been pretty good. On my first day with the phone, I was discharging at around 4.5% an hour. I would expect this to get better with a few more charge cycles.
Finally apps are a concern. I have most of the ones I need but a few apps that are key for me and are gnawing at me for not having them. United airlines, Starbucks and Concur solutions are three. Oh, and Im slightly OCD about my battery level and not having the % on the screen is really annoying. I know there are apps for that but then only update every 30 minutes??
In the end, I have a feeling I will go back to my GS3 but the decision wont be an easy one.
- 11-18-2012, 11:14 AM #6
I'm thinking of either getting the Samsung ativ s or 822. I do think the amoled on the 900 is superior even at a lower pixel ratio. My main issue is that all colors look washed. The whites even look bad. They don't look white; more like dull yellowish white- off white. I like the cool white vs warm off white. It can be a known issue bc its on the list of issues but this doesn't seem to bother anyone? or they aren't having it as bad as me. This really bugs me because really want to keep my 920. I look at the screen more than anything else and I feel like I downgraded from 900 to 920. I understand that amoled has better contrast and black however ips lcd is supposted to have better whites. This is not the case my 900 looks better both whites, blacks, and colors; even on brightness on high. I compared it to a iphone4 and 5, galaxy 3, 8x, onex, motoroll rzr hd. They all make the l920 screen look washed out. It looks like theres a dark screen protector on. I even swapped 2 x and get same results. Maybe a bad batch of matte blacks in Chicago? I compared it to other 920s that aren't matte black they look better too however I want a matte black 920. the reps saw the difference so they swapped it and still has same issue all Chicago stores ran out of matte black. My fiancé says maybe the nokia 920 just sucks. I love everything else about the phone however doesn't do any good if screen display looks bad. even in videos and pics. this really disappoints me I really want to love this phone.
- 11-18-2012, 11:20 AM #7
Mine is going back due to the loose battery. It wouldn't bother me so much if it didn't make a noise that ruins my videos (phone works just fine, but moving around while taking a video results in loud banging noises...). That said, I will stay WP8. Most likely another 920 for me, maybe an 8x. I'll decide when I get back to my store today.
- 11-18-2012, 11:28 AM #8
11-18-2012, 11:51 AM #9
- 36 Posts
I'm second guessing my new phone choice as well. I've got a perfectly working L900 sitting here at home as well as an unlocked Nexus. I bought a L920 off contract and the $449 is pretty tough to swallow. I really love using the L900 as a daily driver but there are so many features I miss from my Nexus. The L900 screen looks great outside, the camera is acceptable to me, and I LOVE how Xbox music is the first choice for music on the phone.
There really does';t seem to be a larger enough gap between WP7 and WP8.... Or between my L900 or my new L920..
The Nexus just seems to have much more going to it. Mint app, Pocket app, Flipboard.... The integration with Google is deep with the Nexus and Google has shown very little love to WP.
- 11-18-2012, 12:05 PM #11
I will most likely be returning my 920 this Tuesday. I really love the os and physical design of the phone is really nice, the only problem I have with the phone is the battery life. I don't know how people get there phones to last a full day, mine only lasts,9-10 hours. I hear it might be whatsapp that's killing my battery but if I can't use whatsapp, then I won't keep the phone. It really is a beautiful phone but I need something that can get me threw the day. I'll probably just go back to my bb 9650 and wait till bb10 comes out. I won't get an iPhone, I might get the n4, never tried android before.
11-18-2012, 12:11 PM #12
- 346 Posts
The battery life issue will get fixed. I personally don't have a problem with the battery but I know some people do. So if you like everything else except that just wait a few weeks (maybe a month) and I am sure Nokia will have a hot fix on the way.
I really like my 920. I plan to keep it. Probably for the whole two years of my contract!
- 11-18-2012, 01:40 PM #13
I was loving everything about my 920 until this morning when it completely froze. I was dialing into voicemail and it comnected and locked up after 3 seconds of connection. The screen is frozen and nothing I do will un-freeze it.
Off to the AT@T store today for a replacement
- 11-18-2012, 02:00 PM #15
- 11-18-2012, 03:03 PM #16
The people going on about how the 900 screen is better than the 920 are taking crazy pills. I mean, opinions are opinions, but the colors on the 900 so blown out, it's not even funny.
I loved the inky blacks too, but not at the expense of every other color being way too intense. The only accent colors I ever used were Nokia Blue and Green. Every other color was way too vivid and bleeding everywhere. The 920 screen is just right, IMO.
I find it so odd that people like blown out and bassy Beats Audio or overblown colors on AMOLED screens or unrealistic iPhone 5 photos. It's like realistic tones and textures aren't enough anymore...
Sent from my RM-820_nam_att_100 using Board Express
- 11-18-2012, 04:32 PM #17
- 11-18-2012, 04:38 PM #18
I'm just waiting for my 14 days to return mine, the 920 hardware wise is almost perfect, but WP8 is not ready yet, I feel like a beta tester. So many top 50 apps missing, no proper DLNA software, no NFC payments, no official Facebook app, Crippled camera software(no custom settings), No official Youtube app ( you cant even upload videos to Youtube). WP8 is just not ready.
11-18-2012, 04:47 PM #19
- 36 Posts
- 11-18-2012, 07:16 PM #20
I knew what to expect with WP8. I knew it would be a little light on the apps, and I knew most websites would look ghetto in IE b/c it's not a WebKit browser. Regardless I love the fast and slick UI. As far as the Lumia:
- Stunning display. Best I've ever used
- amazing build quality
- The Nokia apps were slick
- auto brightness was extremely smooth (something most phones besides iPhone lack)
- Low light pics were awesome
So why did it go back? It's simply too bulky. I can handle the weight but it is thick and large....overall it's just too big for me. It is a major shame the 820 has crappy screen resolution (by today's standards). Side by side the 820 screen was a far cry from the 920. So my only option left was the 8X. No way am I cool with purple or yellow, and there isn't enough space.
Why Nokia couldn't you give me a thinner slightly smaller phone with a screen like the 920? It was hard to return it. I actually left and returned to the store a few times, changing my mind every time I looked at that amazing display. Finally it went back, and now im back to the iPhone 4S. Patiently waiting for a windows phone that better suits me, hopefully by Nokia.
- 11-18-2012, 07:22 PM #22
I've never understood this. The phone isn't heavy, at all. I feel like the media has hyped this up and its making people think more about it then actually realizing the phone weight is fine.
Today I showed a co-worker who has the iPhone 5 my new Lumia 920. He took it out of my hands and side "Man, what a sexy looking phone". Played around with it then gave it back. He asked some questions about the OS and camera then went on about his business. This is an Apple Fanboy who would have zero issues mentioning something negative about my phone. He said nothing regarding the weight. I can understand screen size, some people like a smaller phone... but weight? Really? Like how weak do people have to be to think this phone is heavy....
- 11-18-2012, 07:27 PM #24
That's too bad. The weight thing is really over rated, especially since early reviews made such a big deal out of it. But at least you're not trying to force the phone on yourself. What about the Samsung Ativ? That might suit you better when it's released.
- By Yakkob in forum Upcoming & Rumored Windows PhonesReplies: 108Last Post: 09-14-2012, 07:55 AM
- By J4rrod in forum Windows Phone 7Replies: 14Last Post: 09-28-2011, 11:35 AM
- By malachijd in forum HTC TrophyReplies: 31Last Post: 09-06-2011, 05:48 AM
- By jtn05 in forum Windows Phone 7Replies: 18Last Post: 05-27-2011, 03:30 AM