08-29-2013 01:17 PM
43 12
tools
  1. Arsynic's Avatar
    How is this even possible? This is in relation to the FM Radio option. Let me get this straight, I'll probably never have to use the feature but it's the principle of the matter that needs to be discussed. How can a newer version of basically the same hardware have less functionality? How is this even possible?

    We deserve an explanation to why this is the case. And does this set a precedence for future Nokia phones? None of this makes sense. I'd expect features to be disabled on a budget phone, but not on a so-called flagship device.
    DavidinCT likes this.
    08-21-2013 10:04 AM
  2. hopmedic's Avatar
    08-21-2013 10:05 AM
  3. Arsynic's Avatar
    I read that thread. This topic is about the precedent that this sets with Nokia phones. When I choose the more advanced model of a phone, I expect all of the features of the lesser model and then some. But with Nokia, this seems arbitrary.

    I love WP8, but another carrier needs to step the f-up because Nokia isn't cutting it.
    DavidinCT likes this.
    08-21-2013 10:08 AM
  4. gsquared's Avatar
    Given that is a VZ only device you may want to discuss with the carrier stated many times in the link hopmedic posted.
    08-21-2013 10:14 AM
  5. tk-093's Avatar
    Don't wory, next month Verizon is releasing the 929, Radio Version.
    inteller and xandros9 like this.
    08-21-2013 10:34 AM
  6. hopmedic's Avatar
    There's no precedent here. The 822 has a MicroSD slot. 928 doesn't. Is 928 gimped because of that? It's not even a precedent with this particular model, let alone within Nokia.
    08-21-2013 10:54 AM
  7. SanjitVignesh's Avatar
    I miss the FM Radio on my 620 when a 520 is getting one.
    08-21-2013 11:06 AM
  8. Arsynic's Avatar
    Given that is a VZ only device you may want to discuss with the carrier stated many times in the link hopmedic posted.
    How does this explain the 822?
    08-21-2013 11:07 AM
  9. Beast of Haeven's Avatar
    I love WP8, but another carrier needs to step the f-up because Nokia isn't cutting it.
    You can't be serious??? With all that Nokia is doing and has done, you couldn't possibly mean that just because a flagship lacks an FM radio.
    08-21-2013 11:20 AM
  10. tk-093's Avatar
    When I choose the more advanced model of a phone, I expect all of the features of the lesser model and then some.
    If that's the case, why did you even buy the phone? The 822 has removable storage, it has a removable battery.... Both options are superior to what the 928 has, IMO.
    08-21-2013 11:30 AM
  11. Aaron Bateman's Avatar
    I do not get the fury over the FM radio...
    Rick2340 likes this.
    08-21-2013 11:38 AM
  12. Moiz Mian's Avatar
    There's no precedent here. The 822 has a MicroSD slot. 928 doesn't. Is 928 gimped because of that? It's not even a precedent with this particular model, let alone within Nokia.
    This ^ Even the 520 has a microsd slot. It sucks that there is no FM radio antenna though, but it is what it is. You still have a few radio apps and nokia music if you ever need music in a pinch!
    08-21-2013 12:50 PM
  13. pechio's Avatar
    I read that thread. This topic is about the precedent that this sets with Nokia phones. When I choose the more advanced model of a phone, I expect all of the features of the lesser model and then some. But with Nokia, this seems arbitrary.

    I love WP8, but another carrier needs to step the f-up because Nokia isn't cutting it.
    I love WP8 too... but no FM radio, no wireless syncing (the cloud is way too slow), the tiles do whatever they want to do but updating & the lady from Here drive drives me nuts, telling me every 30 seconds keep left until it's too late to exit on the right.
    08-22-2013 01:57 AM
  14. 3earnhardt3's Avatar
    I was VERY excited for GDR2 because of the FM Radio (I listen to nascar races occasionally, TuneIn supports the station it broadcasts on, but not the nascar programming), and was VERY depressed when GDR2 came out without FM Radio on my 928. Do I believe my phone is Gimped? No. The 822 is an awesome device but I want the awesome camera and screen on the 928 more than I want microSD, FM radio and removable battery on the 822.
    08-23-2013 08:20 AM
  15. 3earnhardt3's Avatar
    I read that thread. This topic is about the precedent that this sets with Nokia phones. When I choose the more advanced model of a phone, I expect all of the features of the lesser model and then some. But with Nokia, this seems arbitrary.

    I love WP8, but another carrier needs to step the f-up because Nokia isn't cutting it.
    Sorry for two responses in a row in this thread... I wish every "flagship" phone I purchase could come with everything I could ever desire, but I find that idea quite unreasonable. There are people who still want a qwerty slider, so lets throw that in; now a 1020 like camera; microSD; removable battery(that is 3000mah for two day use); FM radio; top quality build materials that are near indestructible; 2GB RAM; 1080p screen; etc.

    So now we would all own giant bricks that weigh 300g, are 1/2 inch thick at best and cost a small fortune to own. I bought my 928 two weeks after release for $30, it blows the minds of every friend and family member that sees it(something my poor trophy never could do, even if it was still amazing IMO) and performs 95% of my realistic needs (great phone, great camera, great screen, wonderful OS).
    hopmedic likes this.
    08-23-2013 08:36 AM
  16. pechio's Avatar
    Sorry for two responses in a row in this thread... I wish every "flagship" phone I purchase could come with everything I could ever desire, but I find that idea quite unreasonable. There are people who still want a qwerty slider, so lets throw that in; now a 1020 like camera; microSD; removable battery(that is 3000mah for two day use); FM radio; top quality build materials that are near indestructible; 2GB RAM; 1080p screen; etc.

    ).
    The FM radio is already in the phone & the WiFi syncing too, but somebody doesn't want us to use these functions.
    08-23-2013 09:54 AM
  17. 3earnhardt3's Avatar
    The FM radio is already in the phone & the WiFi syncing too, but somebody doesn't want us to use these functions.
    It is my understanding that the FM receiver is built into the chip but isn't actually connected to anything, which would require additional design/cost. I'm not sticking up for nokia, but they obviously had some reason not to use the builtin FM receiver.
    08-23-2013 10:12 AM
  18. MikeLip's Avatar
    It is my understanding that the FM receiver is built into the chip but isn't actually connected to anything, which would require additional design/cost. I'm not sticking up for nokia, but they obviously had some reason not to use the builtin FM receiver.
    The reason is obvious, and is the reason Verizon does or doesn't do everything. It doesn't benefit their bottom line for them to have it, period. It would either drive up the cost of the phone, be a support problem or, in theory anyway, reduce revenues from sales of data service. It's not some evil conspiracy, unless you count squeezing the customer until every last drop of blood and other valuable bodily fluid is extracted as evil. Some bean counter did the math. That's all it is. Unsatisfying, I know, and it takes the fun out of righteous indignation.
    DavidinCT and xandros9 like this.
    08-23-2013 11:31 AM
  19. hopmedic's Avatar
    It could (not saying it is - just could) be as simple as cost. Yeah, the wire would probably cost a penny or less... But I used to work in the Auto industry, and worked not only for a car manufacturer at one point, but a supplier at another point. At the supplier, where we made seats to supply the car makers, I've seen discussions that lasted six months about whether or not to put something on a seat that was going to cost just a penny. Yeah.... When you're working for a publicly traded company, they do look at that level of cost. A penny per seat, or even a penny per seat set (I don't remember which it was, as I wasn't directly involved, just hearing from my boss), multiplied by millions of cars/seats can add up.
    mase123987, jleebiker and xandros9 like this.
    08-23-2013 12:18 PM
  20. pma's Avatar
    It could have been a design or manufacturing error that wasn't caught until too late. Still, I prefer to blame Verizon because they deserve it
    hopmedic, MikeLip and xandros9 like this.
    08-23-2013 02:03 PM
  21. MikeLip's Avatar
    It could (not saying it is - just could) be as simple as cost. Yeah, the wire would probably cost a penny or less... But I used to work in the Auto industry, and worked not only for a car manufacturer at one point, but a supplier at another point. At the supplier, where we made seats to supply the car makers, I've seen discussions that lasted six months about whether or not to put something on a seat that was going to cost just a penny. Yeah.... When you're working for a publicly traded company, they do look at that level of cost. A penny per seat, or even a penny per seat set (I don't remember which it was, as I wasn't directly involved, just hearing from my boss), multiplied by millions of cars/seats can add up.
    I am (well, was) an electronics engineer, and am now controlling our production and watching supply chain. I am pretty familiar with manufacturing electronics since that's what I do since 1975. I am going to guess for materials to connect to antenna, maybe a few cents. After than perhaps 5 or 10 cents to connect it - much of this work is done by hand, although this is probably nothing more than clipping the wire to the antenna. Still you multiply that over a few million phones, it's starting to look like enough money to by a nice house in Los Angeles or pay off the old Lamborghini.
    hopmedic, mase123987 and jleebiker like this.
    08-23-2013 05:32 PM
  22. MikeLip's Avatar
    It could have been a design or manufacturing error that wasn't caught until too late. Still, I prefer to blame Verizon because they deserve it
    Excellent point! :)
    08-23-2013 05:35 PM
  23. mase123987's Avatar
    It could (not saying it is - just could) be as simple as cost. Yeah, the wire would probably cost a penny or less... But I used to work in the Auto industry, and worked not only for a car manufacturer at one point, but a supplier at another point. At the supplier, where we made seats to supply the car makers, I've seen discussions that lasted six months about whether or not to put something on a seat that was going to cost just a penny. Yeah.... When you're working for a publicly traded company, they do look at that level of cost. A penny per seat, or even a penny per seat set (I don't remember which it was, as I wasn't directly involved, just hearing from my boss), multiplied by millions of cars/seats can add up.
    Most people don't get this. Esp. when talking about electronics, employees are always being pushed to cut costs of parts and manufacturing, even a penny at a time.
    08-23-2013 07:43 PM
  24. pechio's Avatar
    I am (well, was) an electronics engineer, and am now controlling our production and watching supply chain. I am pretty familiar with manufacturing electronics since that's what I do since 1975. I am going to guess for materials to connect to antenna, maybe a few cents. After than perhaps 5 or 10 cents to connect it - much of this work is done by hand, although this is probably nothing more than clipping the wire to the antenna. Still you multiply that over a few million phones, it's starting to look like enough money to by a nice house in Los Angeles or pay off the old Lamborghini.
    Well, did they sell the car with unusable seats, they still would be inside the vehicle.

    I am (well, was) an electronics engineer, and am now controlling our production and watching supply chain. I am pretty familiar with manufacturing electronics since that's what I do since 1975. I am going to guess for materials to connect to antenna, maybe a few cents. After than perhaps 5 or 10 cents to connect it - much of this work is done by hand, although this is probably nothing more than clipping the wire to the antenna. Still you multiply that over a few million phones, it's starting to look like enough money to by a nice house in Los Angeles or pay off the old Lamborghini.
    As a reminder all the new Lumias have the radio connected (see the pic below) only the model for Verizon doesn't. It's nice marketing move "you pay more for less"
    lumia928_radio.jpg
    08-23-2013 09:28 PM
  25. MikeLip's Avatar
    No one here, or anywhere, is going to say anything to make you like this. And nothing that is said here is going to change it. There is a saying in engineering - "It is what it is." Verizon just does not really care too much if you are happy as an individual or not. They made the decision for what seemed to them to be a good reason. Whether it is objectively good is not necessarily so, but it is what it is. You have a decision to make; use the phone (and it's a darned nice phone, FM or no) or don't. There are other carriers and other phones. But the other carriers won't really be any better because their motivations are identical to Verizons; suck as much money from your wallet as possible, just short of starvation, because dead customers don't pay their bills.
    08-23-2013 10:20 PM
43 12

Similar Threads

  1. [Lumia 822] Firmware 3045.0000.1328.1031 download
    By tungha in forum Nokia Lumia 822
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 01-05-2015, 01:06 AM
  2. WTS: TMo Lumia 810 w/ GDR2/Amber update (Cracked Screen)
    By b3rni3703 in forum Marketplace Archive
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 08-25-2013, 02:31 PM
  3. Best damage protection for Nokia Lumia 820?
    By kitty778 in forum Nokia Lumia 820
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 08-22-2013, 10:44 AM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD