Normally, I don't ask for opinions on a device for me, because what's great for me may not be for someone else. but, in this case I really like both phones and would love to see what you guys think. One of the reasons why I opted against purchasing the Lumia 920, is because it was so thick to me. I just prefer a thinner phone. I was all set to either order the Ativ S or the Lumia 928 when the story of the Catwalk reminded me about what I originally wanted to purchase. I had completely forgotten about it! LOL! So, here's the dilemma...I really wanted a WP device with a larger screen and thinner body, which is why I wanted the Ativ S. However, the Catwalk is rumored to have a thinner body with 4.5 in display. The second dilemma is that I haven't owned a Nokia device in decades, and I am a little concerned with the issues that have been floating around lately. I know they are a great company that will fix bugs and support customers in an awesome and quick way...but I'd rather not have those issues to begin with. I don't want dust and proximity sensor issues, or "Other" storage issues, or connectivity issues. I'm afraid that I may need to have the repair center on speed dial! Though I know each phone/company has their issues, I want to have an ease of mind when purchasing my next device...so what do you think?