- 05-29-2012, 05:49 PM #1
I can't figure this one out...when you hit the search button the keyboard is closed until you tap on the text-entry box.
That is very silly, it adds an unnecessary step! I just saw the windows 8 "search" button does the same thing on a tablet. (In iOS the search area automatically opens the keyboard.)
Has this strange UI choice in WP7 bothered anyone else?
- 05-29-2012, 05:57 PM #2
cause theirs is like 4+ other things you can do aside from typing.
- Music search
- to see the nice BING pic with Information related to it. the key bored would block that.( think this might be the real reason LOL )
and you select what you want and if not you click with your finger in the search.
I find this very convenient considering i almost NEVER use text to search, always voice or music search...
but that's just me i guess , I like it.
- 05-29-2012, 06:33 PM #4
Also, the other options are available with the keyboard open (if you haven't noticed). The whole point of the search key is supposed to be convenience, and adding extra steps runs coutner to that.
Here's a suggestion if you really want the picture: make the keyboard semi-transparent untile you type on it (or it disappears if you click the picture you are eager to see).
I guess I expect a little more since I came to WP7 from webOS, which had exceptional search capabilties and could do many of these task in half the steps that it takes in WP7.
[Se1fcr3ation, I hope you will forgive me a little combativeness in my response, I like WP7 alot...I guess that's why I get frustrated when I see a deficiency, especially one that other platforms handily avoid]
- 05-29-2012, 07:06 PM #5
I can see your point of view on that matter for sure,
but honestly I dont think MS looks at that as a deficiency but more of a new innovative feature that other phones dont have.
for example: the search on the Iphone;, the keyboard comes right up , but its boring and ugly. just a square static looking keyboard with a search bar.. lol ( again that's my opinion)
compare to WP`s nice Bing experiance with that nice new PIC every day! :P lol
regarding WEBOS I used it as well and honestly you cant really compare the *search Menu* on WP to a *just type* feature on webos. witch was an other great feature in Webos.
ether way I dont think we will see this change any time soon if ever as I Believe MS is really looking at this as a *cool* thing.
no harm in having your voice heard, you never know people might vote for it!
MS suggestion page for WP customers - Creat suggestions or vote on your fav
and you can also get the APP on your phone! (lol) : Suggestion Box
any ways , only time will tell what the future holds for us!:happy:
Last edited by Se1fcr3ation; 05-29-2012 at 07:13 PM.
- 05-29-2012, 08:50 PM #7
- 05-29-2012, 10:19 PM #9
This thread is a good example of all the nitpicking that goes around WPCentral forums. Not saying this isn't a valid complaint, but it's one that is nothing but nitpicking.
As it was already said, the Search menu is not just for writing stuff. For example, if I want to go to Bing Vision, I don't need the keyboard. Why would I need it to be there after I pressed the search button?
Last edited by Seketh; 05-29-2012 at 10:26 PM. Reason: spelling...
- 05-29-2012, 11:43 PM #12
I don't think we're flaming the guy, I mean, if there's a thread were the word "nitpicking" can be used, it's this one.
- 05-30-2012, 10:33 AM #13
- 05-30-2012, 11:03 AM #14
the attraction in out time and age is all about being different and innovative
I Find MS does a GREAT job at being innovative and attractive , even with the few functions missing
and honestly id Much rather a nice PIC on the BING search then a keyboard popping up.
I wasn't going to say thing but..
If you find that clicking on the search bar to get the Keyboard to come up takes TO MUCH TIME ( a full 0.5sec) then MAYBE , JUST MAYBE you shouldn't have a phone at all.
LOUIS CK said it the best: *Everything is Amazing & nobody is Happy :lol:
(obviously its not but its the meaning that matters)
- 05-30-2012, 01:55 PM #16
05-30-2012, 02:20 PM #17
- 414 Posts
Local scout doesn't have to be there because you can have a tile for that.
The musical note key is for a music search.
The eye is a barcode scanner.
The mic is for a vocal search.
To be honest, I use the vocal search much more often so I'm glad it defaults the way it does. There is nothing wrong with the way Bing searches, it's just a matter of preference.
- 05-30-2012, 07:12 PM #18
I guess a person should put on a flame-retardent suit before entering these forums ;) Is this nitpicking? I suppose it could be called that, but 'search' is supposed to be a big part of WP7; after all it is one of the only hardware buttons and they killed contextual search in favor of making this Bing search page open no matter when the search button is pressed. I merely started this thread to see if others found the extra step of opening the keyboard an unnecessary frustration.
I guess I have learned that there are others who like having the extra-step, so maybe this isn't a deficiency and MS has got things right!
However, I can't quite agree because it was Microsoft that advertizes WP7 as "faster" OS which is supposed to use less taps/clicks/steps. I can't help but feel that this search/keyboard thing is an example of where that philosophy is not put into practice.
Resume flaming ;) (in case it isn't clear, i am joking and i hardly think any comments here are out of line)
- 05-30-2012, 08:29 PM #20
- 05-30-2012, 08:52 PM #22
Because opening the keyboard every time would block Bing Vision, Bing Music, Local Scout ect, and force people to click back to remove keyboard to see them. That would serve to assume people always want to do a text search.
-- I should have tested before posting, but the keyboard does not cover the other functions. This would be nice to have the keyboard pop up automatically. Although I think Bing has a thing for showing the Bing Images ;p
Last edited by dtboos; 05-31-2012 at 11:37 AM.
- 05-30-2012, 09:24 PM #23
Also, your last line ("most of which are somewhat faster") is exactly my point.
In any case, I'm starting to regret that I ever posted this thread...
- 05-30-2012, 09:49 PM #25
I don't think this is a major issue, but I think it would be nice to have something similar to the search page on the iphone. One swipe and you start typing, plus it searches the phone and the web. I hope WP has adds similar functionality to Bing search in WP 8.