09-21-2012, 03:29 PM #1
- 19 Posts
Do you think WP Tiles need a facelift?
I know that beauty is a personal thing but I am asking this question because I think the tiles are ugly. I own the Lumia 900 and put my iPhone in the drawer awhile back.
What I miss that I feel WP lacks is the sex appeal of the iPhone. I personally feel that is one area Microsoft needs to improve.
I'd love to hear the forums feedback. A poll would also be a nice thing to build the facts.
I personally have skin in this game as a Microsoft shareholder but I'd like to hear what others think
Thanks in advance for your feedback.
- 09-21-2012, 03:49 PM #4
Even many Apple designers are getting sick of the iOS software design. Here is a good article about it. It's not sexy, it's tacky.
Will Apple's Tacky Software-Design Philosophy Cause A Revolt? | Co.Design: business + innovation + design
Skeuomorphism is a word I just learned today. :)
- 09-21-2012, 04:11 PM #10
Nope, not ugly at all.
It is actually the new tiled layout that caught my eye and as a result I'm gonna be getting my first Windows phone, a Lumia 820!
It is very refreshing and different to anything else out there. Perhaps the icon/grid look has had it's day?
I must be honest, I did look at wp7 phones but they layout wasn't as nice (in my opinion) mainly because of the black bar at the side of the screen. I didn't think this look could be improved upon but I was wrong.
There are endless ways that this screen can be customised. Pictures, icons, live tiles, different shapes, sizes and colours..... Lovely!
- 09-21-2012, 04:21 PM #12
As for looks, nothing is better than live tiles. The phone is alive and gives you the important information at a glance.
The icon grid of iOS is not good looking or sexy. However if you want to do a poll you can, but you will find you are in the minority.
I know even some of my Android and iPhone friends like the look of my phone. I get asked questions a lot whenever someone sees the tiles flipping and showing their information.
- 09-21-2012, 04:32 PM #13
As others have said, there is absolutely nothing that is sexy with regards to iOS. I hate the fact that you must have every app, regardless of whether you use it or not, on your homescreen. Also, other than the number of alerts from each app, there is no information whatsoever available to you unless you open the app or check the notification panel. Heck, even the weather app can't show you the current temperature without opening it. Android goes a step further by allowing you to place apps and widgets on the homescreens but I just don't see it at being nearly as cohesive as the Windows Phone OS.
So long as WP8 provides us with a better web browser and a larger app library, I can't imagine myself giving Android or iOS another look. The only other OS that I feel can be competitive would be BB10 if they are able to break their reliance on BES/BIS. I had a PlayBook for a little while and even when it was first released, the OS showed a lot of promise despite the fact that it was essentially a public beta and lacked a lot of core functionality.
- 09-22-2012, 02:30 AM #18
Where Apple has shown lack of vision is the in the UI. Essentially they took the "icon view" from their Mac OS desktop and pasted it onto a smartphone app drawer. No imagination whatsoever. Sure they made them prettier with lighting effects and higher resolution then the old icons but they're still the same dumb app launcher shortcuts that they are. Also every single app you download MUST.APPEAR.IN.APP.DRAWER.
Also the app drawer only can contain application shortcuts. No live tiles. No other content like contacts, maps, stock symbols or any other content you could imagine. The same holds for Windows 8 as for Windows Phone in terms of pinning content that you want to the start screen and having a separate Application List!
Microsoft is way more innovative in software design these days then Apple, but Apple still makes great hardware.
- 09-22-2012, 02:35 AM #19
Let me summarize the difference between iOS & Windows Phone.
iOS start screen = dumb application shortcuts, shallow links to the home page of an app
WP start screen = pinned applications & content. live tiles and deep links in some cases. So a stock symbol will not only open the stock app, but navigate you to the symbol details. What in iOS can do that?
- 09-22-2012, 03:37 AM #20
And as Paladri said, iOS BADLY needs a new facelift.
Its not only a beautiful design, its a benchmark. A case study. Of how people can think outside the proverbial box and bring a fresh concept to life.
Sent from my XT910 using Xparent Cyan Tapatalk 2
- 09-22-2012, 10:59 PM #21
One thing I can agree with is that when you have too many tiles which only have the accent color + a white icon they can blend together in a heaping mess. The reason why iOS is so successful is that when you're look at the app drawer, the icons are so distinct from each other that you have no trouble knowing which app is which. That can be a problem on Windows Phone.
- 09-22-2012, 11:10 PM #22
I love the live tile interface of wp. The grid of static icons with glass texture and rounded corners bores me. I like that crazy amounts of personal data can be gleaned by unlocking the phone and scrolling down thru my home screen. It doesn't need faux glass texture, or anything. It was born to be viewed on a screen, it should be bold and clean and square.
Sent from my SGH-i917 using Board Express