- 06-05-2013, 12:02 PM #1
I'm sad to say this but I'm considering jumping ship over to Android and grab an HTC One.
When WP7 launched I quickly bought an LG Optimus 7 that served me very well without any issues. As soon as WP8 launched I bought an HTC 8X that works great to this day and I absolutely loved it. It's the best phone I've ever had.
Two weeks ago, my mom was up for renewal (she had an Optimus 7 like the one I had since WP7 launch). She asked me if I wanted to give her my 8X for a yellow Lumia 920 she could get with her renewal. After considering it for a couple of days, I said yes mainly for the better rear camera and the LTE support.
The Lumia 920 suffered very poor battery life and random overheating/draining issues in the first few days and came with a light bleeding near the height of the back button. Unfortunately, here in Mexico some companies (in this case, my carrier Telcel) can still do what they want and screw over its own customers and its a real PITA to make them exchange defective products. They said the battery was fine when it was lasting me 6-8 hrs, even when I was in WiFi all the time and using the phone just a little. They first called the light bleeding a "cosmetic issue" with the intention of not honoring the warranty.
After many complains, I got with a supervisor and they opened two more yellow Lumia 920's and they both had the light bleeding defect. This is only high end WP8 phone they have and the only one I want besides my great 8X. My current situation is that I can get them to give me another brand/model but the 920 is out of the question for the light bleeding defect and the fear the ones they have will suffer from very poor battery life as well.
The Lumia 925 could be a great phone but it's not yet available and I need a new phone right now. After seeing the great design and features of the HTC One I'm considering getting one, use it until the 925 is broadly available and issues are reported (I don't want to suffer the issues I had with the 920) to see if I keep the One or sell it to buy a 925.
What do you guys think? I really like and think WP8 is the best smartphone OS right now and it keeps improving but the 920 issues sounds like Nokia is dropping the ball and probably it would be at least 2-4 months or more before I can get the 925 here in Mexico.
Is this a good strategy? The HTC One is getting superb reviews all over the place and the design (the reason I got the 8X and not a 90 on WP8 launch) is awesome.
I still could give my mom the HTC One and get my 8X back but after seeing the LTE speeds and the camera of the 920, I kind of want it to upgrade it. The One's camera is one of the best out there after the 920 and also has a wide-angle FFC like the 8X and I love being able to get myself and a lot of people when using it, even when it was just a pic here and there. All phones should come with a wide-angle FFC.
I felt like venting my problems could help me forget about this terrible situation with the issues of the 920, at least the ones that Nokia made available in Mexico. What do you guys think? Thanks for reading, I hope I didn't just bored you to death with this rant :)
- 06-05-2013, 12:29 PM #2
"I had a great experience with two Windows Phones, I got a 3rd one and it was the only one that was horrible. I'm going to Android"
In all seriousness though, do what makes you happy. Getting the One isn't a bad move, neither is trading the One for your 8X back. Play around with the One for a bit and see how you like it first.
- 06-06-2013, 01:40 AM #3
I already bought the One and ti should arrive on Friday. I plan on keeping it until the Lumia is available 925 or a more worthy Windows Phone is presented. The jumping ship parts is, I hope and I want, temporal as I really like WP8 above other OSes.
The good thing is that I can change the One with my 8X if I want to. In the end, after all the headaches returning the 920 with my carrier, I think it is a win-win for me at this time.
I'm not jumping ship, I'm making a pit stop or something like that :D
- 06-06-2013, 03:20 AM #4
I'm personally giving WP until the Blue update to see whether it's worth sticking around. I'm about 80% happy with the phone and the OS so even though that's pretty high, that 20% that's missing is quite important to me. Hopefully MS sees these issues and corrects them cause I think they're more OS based than anything to do with Nokia.
- 06-06-2013, 12:25 PM #7
I could happily accepted another 920 from carrier to see if it didn't have battery problems, but they had the light leaking and I really thought it was not worth it, even when I'm a big WP fan from the beginning.
- 06-06-2013, 02:54 PM #8
I had a Droid for 2.5 years and I'll never get one again: the Android operating system is just a sluggish mess. It was painfully slow, unintuitive, and unstable. I just hopped on board the Windows Phone 8 train, picking up the 928 a few weeks ago and what a breath of fresh air. The operating system is amazing: smooth, fast, intuitive, and fresh. I love it.
- 06-06-2013, 03:15 PM #10
If it were me, I would stick it out with the 920, problems and all, until the next phone I had my eye on was released. But why would you jump ship to Android just because of your experience with the Lumia 920 when you had such a good experience with the 8X? I don't get that...
- 06-06-2013, 05:15 PM #11
Dood, I'm telling you right now, don't bother getting any android device that isn't a Nexus branded one. You'll never get updates, especially from an HTC device. I don't care if its the HTC *insert your favorite number here*, it won't get updated fast, and that sense interface gets stale after about 5 minutes. The best android experience is on a Nexus device. I've had a Nexus 4 since launch and its fantastic. The HTC One in my opinion, is like putting a really nice dress on a duck. At the end of the day, its still a damn duck.
Now that I got my opinion on the best android phone choice (a galaxy nexus, nexus 4) out of the way, here is my advice on why you should calm down and rethink going to android.
The amber update is coming really soon. All WP8 devices will receive it and a great deal of improvement will be had on every phone. Once Jelly Bean 4.3 or Key Lime Pie 5.0 comes out, you're going to be waiting close to year at maybe receiving an update.. unless you buy a developer Google HTC One. Anyway, I'm talking way to much, just keep you're 920. I got rid of my 920 around launch and I regretted it everytime I saw how much WP8 was progressing. The most exciting phone platform right now is WP8 because it is completely new and exciting in every way. Don't do it man, don't go back to android!
- 06-06-2013, 06:34 PM #13
If they release a new phone in a few months time, I will gladly sell the One if I don't like it that much and get one of these.
I couldn't think of keeping the Lumia 920 because of the light leak and the faulty or underperforming battery I suffered. My carrier showed me two more with the same screen factory defect, so keeping it would be a mistake if they ended up lasting only a few hours. It's a real PITA to reclaim warranties or exchange phones with them.
My plan is to roll with the HTC One until the new gen of Windows Phones is launched. I can sell it at a fair price and bought one of the new WP devices at any time.
This will serve me as an interesting experience with Android after having a Kindle Fire and a Nexus 7 for reading and entertainment. A die-hard Windows Phone user taking a taste of the latest gen of Android.
- 06-06-2013, 09:59 PM #14
Fact is that all phone platforms are going to have forums that have what appears to be a high percentage of people complaining. That's because average people don't hang out (or even likely hear about) forums like this one, and the people who are here are the ones who are going to notice the problems the most, and voice them. The majority of people aren't even going to notice some of the things we see here, because half of us here are OCD. We see the gunk behind the start button. They see, "Oh, shiny!"
Don't let what you see here be your guide as to what phone to go with. Go look for yourself.
06-06-2013, 10:31 PM #15
- 150 Posts
I have had a bad experience to. I got my wp7 phone in 2011 LG quantum and had no problems!!! I love the os! So when wp8 can out right when best buy preorders came out I got a cyan 920, it got stuck and all this crap and basically it took 2 months to get my phone, the phone had internal issues, they were out of cyans when I went to take it in so they gave me a black, that one the flash had broke. Not much to complain about but I like to take photos and that was really getting on my nerve so I got a new one they gave me a cyan and that's were I am now and everything looks good, so lets hope for the best
- 06-07-2013, 03:21 AM #16
Keep in mind your 'average person' will simply return a phone and go with something else when it fails on them cause it pissed them off. We have no idea of the statistics of how many people have returned their phones due to these types of issues and gone with something else.
Last edited by N_LaRUE; 06-07-2013 at 07:18 AM.
06-07-2013, 04:56 AM #18
- 340 Posts
Ultimately, you have to do what makes you happy. You are after all, paying the bill.
I am puzzled however, by why you're not considering other WP options like the Ativ S or a Lumia 720? It seems to me an easier option than jumping to an operating system which is inherently insecure and where you will have to transfer your personal data all over again, rather than have it sync to the new device automatically.
It seems to me that unless you have to have a premium device, there are options you haven't considered.
- 06-07-2013, 08:28 AM #20
I've had Iphones.... Android (Xperia U, S, etc...) and now Windows Phone (Lumia 710 and now 720).... I NEVER GO BACK TO ANDROID OR IOS.
You must have whats makes you happy, if android make it, go for it....
if Android or ios doesn't... COME BACK TO WINDOWS PHONE!!!
- 06-08-2013, 11:16 AM #21
As I said before, returning to Windows Phone in the mid term (before year's end) is on my plans, unless the next wave of WP devices (with the Blue or GDR2 update) is uninteresting.
Windows Phone is and will be my personal favorite OS from a functionality and visual perspective. Right now, Android offers a more advanced OS with plenty of customization options.
You are right, nobody has to be "married" to a platform. I've been using WP from WP7 to WP8 and I hope to come back sooner than later but after hacing the One for a couple of days, it won't be an easy choice though. Nokia, HTC and Samsung need to step their game and launch great phones in their next wave.
- 06-08-2013, 12:06 PM #22
Ultimately, you have to do what you feel is best for you, and only you can determine what that is.
But if you feel that WP8 is the best smartphone OS, why don't you just keep the 920 and "suffer" through the light bleeding issue until you can get a 928?
- 06-09-2013, 09:55 PM #23
It's been three days with the HTC One now and I'm happy. I'm enjoying great battery life already, have customized it to my hearts content (an Android strength) and all the apps WP doesn't have yet. Its been a refreshing change. Sense 5 on the One is way underrated, it is stylish, looks and works great and also provides well thought features over stock Android.
I miss the start screen with Live tiles of WP and the UI of some apps. I think I can live with the One (it's an awesome device) several months until the WP 8.1 phones come out.
If not, I can happily return to the 8X I gave to my mom at anytime. Only time will tell :)
- By usengyap in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 159Last Post: 08-31-2013, 12:51 AM
- By saintforlife in forum Upcoming & Rumored Windows PhonesReplies: 59Last Post: 02-27-2013, 03:48 PM
- By anilraj in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 60Last Post: 01-02-2013, 09:11 PM
- By Hiiiiiiiii in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 21Last Post: 12-20-2012, 04:04 PM
- By Timture in forum Upcoming & Rumored Windows PhonesReplies: 10Last Post: 09-12-2012, 10:19 AM