Welcome to the Windows Central Forums Create Your Account or Ask a Question Answers in 5 minutes - no registration required!
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 26
Like Tree14Likes
  1. njnbat's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    92 Posts
       #1  
    NFC Tags - Windows Phone Os Far Behind

    Nokia lumia 920 has nfc technology in it and nfc tags are currently one of the best accessories to make use of this technology along with the other uses of nfc like sharing ,connecting to nfc enabled speakers etc.
    NFC tags help smartphone users to toggle their profile settings seamlessly and perform multiple actions by swiping their phones over the tags.
    There are many practical uses of NFC and its very helpful in automating our daily tasks .
    But due to the policies in windows phone os, i am wondering how we can make use of this technology to automate things using nfc tags eventhough there are quite a few apps to write nfc tags in store.

    First and foremost the confirmation prompt for toggling the settings is not helping the cause of nfc tags.
    Secondly the absence of automating multiple tasks for windowsphone using store apps is resulting in cutting down the benefits of nfc tags.

    Due to the above points currently nfc tags are increasing the steps to perform tasks in windows phone wherein apps like task launcher in android is able to do wonders for smartphone users.

    Is microsoft working towards removing the prompt screen and is it possible for windows phone 0S to support multitasking of nfc tags.

    Can we expect any improvements in feature ?

    Pls vote for this in below link if you feel its required. There are close to 2000 votes now.

    NFC tagg system changes


    Some articles showing the practical uses of nfc for smartphone users are listed here for reference.
    How to make tags with Multiple Actions
    15 Creative And Useful Ways To Use NFC Tags With Your Phone - trendblog.net
    Noob1ee and Aholman like this.
  2. #2  
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  3. WanderingTraveler's Avatar

    Posts
    4,802 Posts
    Global Posts
    4,812 Global Posts
    PIN
    Email
    #3  
    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    For me, at least, Windows Phone NFC is useless. As for those automating apps, Microsoft may not allow them due to security restrictions.

    It's a shame, though. Nokia pushed this harrd.
    Reviver of Forum Games! I'm TheWPCTraveler over on Nintendo Life, as well. You'll also find me over at gamrConnect as well, because I like numbers.

    3DS Friend Code: 1779-1560-3109 | NNID: TheWPCTraveler
    Devices: Lumia 630, ASUS T100, Nintendo 3DS XL.
    Now Playing: Conception II: Children of the Seven Stars [3DS]
    Now Watching: Pom Poko (平成狸合戦ぽんぽこ)


    I have a creepy avatar, don't I?
  4. njnbat's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    92 Posts
       #4  
    Yeah,nokia is really trying hard by bringing in apps accessories like nfc writer,DT 910,900 ,CR 200.
    But windows policies and security restrictions are not helping nfc in the larger scale.
    lets hope nokia's efforts in nfc doesn't go in vain .
  5. neo158's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,939 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,028 Global Posts
    #5  
    Give me the VISA Paywave app from the GS3 on my ATIV S and I'll be happy!!!!
  6. njnbat's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    92 Posts
       #6  
    Have any one used nfc tags with wp8 . If yes, then can u pls share the best implementation methods possible currently with windows phone.
    Currently i use it to do below activities but still figuring out if i m missing any thing better than these.
    1.Open Here drive
    2.Send message to a contact
    3.Initiate calls
    4.Open website.
  7. AngryNil's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,382 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,387 Global Posts
    #7  
    Quote Originally Posted by WanderingTraveler View Post
    As for those automating apps, Microsoft may not allow them due to security restrictions.
    Microsoft has made really brain-dead decisions for Windows Phone in the name of security (no email image auto-load, anyone?). They annoyingly restrict all users in some aspects, then omit features which prevent the platform from being deployed in business anyway. I don't see why a tag shouldn't be able to perform actual actions, and many of them at that. If someone has my phone and my tag, I've got bigger things to worry about than my WiFi going off.
    njnbat likes this.
  8. neo158's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,939 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,028 Global Posts
    #8  
    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Microsoft has made really brain-dead decisions for Windows Phone in the name of security (no email image auto-load, anyone?). They annoyingly restrict all users in some aspects, then omit features which prevent the platform from being deployed in business anyway. I don't see why a tag shouldn't be able to perform actual actions, and many of them at that. If someone has my phone and my tag, I've got bigger things to worry about than my WiFi going off.
    Two things, No image auto load is to prevent exploits that hide threats in images and the same thing happens in Outlook and the Windows 8 Mail apps for the same reason and Microsoft are going to be releasing an Enterprise feature pack which should help deployment in businesses.
    njnbat likes this.
  9. gsquared's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,374 Posts
    #9  
    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Microsoft has made really brain-dead decisions for Windows Phone in the name of security (no email image auto-load, anyone?). They annoyingly restrict all users in some aspects, then omit features which prevent the platform from being deployed in business anyway. I don't see why a tag shouldn't be able to perform actual actions, and many of them at that. If someone has my phone and my tag, I've got bigger things to worry about than my WiFi going off.
    I believe you are being very short-sighted. I can tell you are an Android user by your statements. Its those same security restrictions that will eventually allow WP to catch up to Android. Currently, Android has to be heavily customized and locked down before it can be introduced into any sensitive environments (ie: enterprise / government). Granted it's "openness" makes it a great consumer platform but the potential downsides are too much for it to be a serious contender in the business and government environments.

    Getting back on topic. NFC tags are a cool technology but the potential for abuse is too high for it to be nothing more than a novelty at this time.
    Support your third-party developers. There just about all we have...
    hopmedic likes this.
  10. #10  
    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Microsoft has made really brain-dead decisions for Windows Phone in the name of security (no email image auto-load, anyone?). They annoyingly restrict all users in some aspects, then omit features which prevent the platform from being deployed in business anyway. I don't see why a tag shouldn't be able to perform actual actions, and many of them at that. If someone has my phone and my tag, I've got bigger things to worry about than my WiFi going off.
    This is a very closed-minded and uneducated statement. The "restrictions" that you are not used to, since obviously you come from Android, are in the name of security, the major area where Android is a huge failure. It isn't necessarily a matter of whether someone has your phone or not. NFC tags can be hidden just about anywhere. Without the prompt, you could set your phone down on a book (just one example), not knowing that the tag is in the book, and it will execute. Without a restriction to keep tags or links from making changes to your OS, who knows what's going on in your phone. Making the user accept the contents of a tag just plain makes sense.

    Now I would say that there is room for improvement. For example, why not have an option that if a tag is accepted once, then it is accepted every time (user controllable option - can turn this off)? That makes sense to me. But no one said that the current NFC implementation is a final product from MS. But for the system settings to be changed? I'm in agreement with their implementation unless they do implement something like I've suggested.

    Quote Originally Posted by neo158 View Post
    Two things, No image auto load is to prevent exploits that hide threats in images and the same thing happens in Outlook and the Windows 8 Mail apps for the same reason and Microsoft are going to be releasing an Enterprise feature pack which should help deployment in businesses.
    Also, no image auto-load reduces data use. I usually don't download images, and I appreciate that they don't auto load, for both your stated reason and mine.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
    waazzupppp likes this.
  11. AngryNil's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,382 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,387 Global Posts
    #11  
    Quote Originally Posted by neo158 View Post
    Two things, No image auto load is to prevent exploits that hide threats in images… Microsoft are going to be releasing an Enterprise feature pack which should help deployment in businesses.
    Outlook.com doesn't do this, or at least has a trusted list. But sure, maybe Microsoft should disable internet connectivity altogether to prevent exploits. And you're telling me Microsoft is apparently so progressive in security features that it has blocked email images for 3 years but still hasn't gotten around to adding VPN support?

    Quote Originally Posted by gsquared View Post
    I can tell you are an Android user by your statements.
    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    since obviously you come from Android
    Cute. You're both dead wrong, congratulations.

    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    Also, no image auto-load reduces data use. I usually don't download images, and I appreciate that they don't auto load, for both your stated reason and mine.
    Ever heard of… choice? It's a beautiful thing.
  12. #12  
    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Cute. You're both dead wrong, congratulations.
    Doubt it. Looks like posts of an Android user to me...
    http://forums.androidcentral.com/sea...archid=4443439


    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Ever heard of… choice? It's a beautiful thing.
    Yup. We chose what we wanted. Apparently you didn't. It would be great if people would do their research before making a purchase.....
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
    Thanked by:
    neo158 
    neo158 likes this.
  13. pvcleave's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    177 Posts
    Global Posts
    184 Global Posts
    #13  
    I have really been disappointed with NFC in Windows Phone. I have a couple of Nokia devices that I can use NFC to pair to, but I do that once and they are paired. It isn't that hard to pair manually anyways. When I heard NFC was going to be on the 920 I was excited, but I am unable to do any of the things Android can do. That one feature is not important enough for me to switch to Android at this point, but I would still like to have it.
    njnbat likes this.
  14. #14  
    I consider it a start. Surely there is more functionality coming. For one thing, the NFC API is open for developers to use, so there's the question of what can come based on creativity of the devs. Nokia has a challenge on their DVLUP site (kind of a game/rewards thing for developers) to create a game using NFC, and another one to implement NFC in your existing game. I'm not a game dev, and don't view myself creative enough so I haven't bothered to read the details, but I know the challenges are there. Not only that, but almost certainly Microsoft as well as Nokia are working on further advancements in the functionality. I'm going to guess that whatever they come up with, though, it's going to keep the phone's security as a top priority.

    The way I understand it, NFC isn't just a way to store data and pass it to a device. I could be wrong, as I haven't studied it, but the way I understand it, you could actually store an executable program in an NFC chip, so yes, security is important.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  15. sinime's Avatar

    Posts
    3,016 Posts
    Global Posts
    4,452 Global Posts
    PIN
    No
    #15  
    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    I consider it a start. Surely there is more functionality coming. For one thing, the NFC API is open for developers to use, so there's the question of what can come based on creativity of the devs. Nokia has a challenge on their DVLUP site (kind of a game/rewards thing for developers) to create a game using NFC, and another one to implement NFC in your existing game. I'm not a game dev, and don't view myself creative enough so I haven't bothered to read the details, but I know the challenges are there. Not only that, but almost certainly Microsoft as well as Nokia are working on further advancements in the functionality. I'm going to guess that whatever they come up with, though, it's going to keep the phone's security as a top priority.

    The way I understand it, NFC isn't just a way to store data and pass it to a device. I could be wrong, as I haven't studied it, but the way I understand it, you could actually store an executable program in an NFC chip, so yes, security is important.
    Or a link to a malicious web site that does some bad mojo
    My Apps: PIP (WP8 - Compass / Flashlight), Meme 8 Ball (WP8), UnClocked (WP8.1 - Themed Live Tile Clock)
  16. #16  
    Quote Originally Posted by sinime View Post
    Or a link to a malicious web site that does some bad mojo
    That, too. I'm sure there are lots of ways to use NFC maliciously, which is why I am fine with the current security model.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  17. ag1986's Avatar
    Banned

    Posts
    488 Posts
    #17  
    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    The way I understand it, NFC isn't just a way to store data and pass it to a device. I could be wrong, as I haven't studied it, but the way I understand it, you could actually store an executable program in an NFC chip, so yes, security is important.
    You understand it wrong. NFC can hold a maximum of 32 kilobytes. Not much you can do with that...

    NFC has been approved for usage by both Mastercard and Visa, and these payment terminals are common in the UK at many large retailers. I doubt that they ignored security.
    AngryNil and njnbat like this.
  18. ag1986's Avatar
    Banned

    Posts
    488 Posts
    #18  
    Quote Originally Posted by sinime View Post
    Or a link to a malicious web site that does some bad mojo
    OMG yes, we must disable the browser immediately, someone might click on a link that "does some bad mojo", won't someone think of the children!!
    AngryNil likes this.
  19. #19  
    Quote Originally Posted by ag1986 View Post
    You understand it wrong. NFC can hold a maximum of 32 kilobytes. Not much you can do with that...

    NFC has been approved for usage by both Mastercard and Visa, and these payment terminals are common in the UK at many large retailers. I doubt that they ignored security.
    You'd be surprised at what you can do with such a small amount of storage. I wrote programs on a computer with 16K in 1980. There are still contests today to see who can come up with the most impressive use of 48K. Do not underestimate what can be done with 32K.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  20. #20  
    And I'm talking 3D graphics in 48K, too.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  21. njnbat's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    92 Posts
       #21  
    From what you guys have shared, i feel 2 points have come up strongly.
    1. Security is very important and lets not play with it . Even i don't want my phone to go dead due to security issues. That will be the last thing i should expect from a reputed OS.
    2.NFC is a growing technology with tremendous potential for both home and enterprises. Its being pushed by banks too and hence this requires support from great companies like Microsoft,Nokia.
    So what are we looking at as best possible solution to this scenario.How can microsoft do something to help us use nfc with best security in place.
    i feel the below option is helpful.
    Let the confirmation messages be there while scanning tags , but giving an option to enable it as a trusted one ,so that the prompts wont come from then on.
    If this is still a security issue, pls share the impacts.If there are more ideas , please share .
    Being a windows phone user i really want to use latest techs and implementations rather than waiting for other's to use them and then microsoft following the path.
    Currently android is doing it even if it is not so secure. So will microsoft take nfc to the next level and allow effective implementation of nfc tags ?
    hopmedic likes this.
  22. AngryNil's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,382 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,387 Global Posts
    #22  
    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    We chose what we wanted. Apparently you didn't. It would be great if people would do their research before making a purchase.....
    Oh, okay. You chose arbitrary restrictions that you will defend until Microsoft reverses them, then you'll be all for it suddenly. I chose a flawed but exciting platform in my Omnia 7. I stayed with the flawed but exciting with my 8X purchase this year. But sure, I'm an Android user based off a few posts on AndroidCentral. Nice deduction, these 1500 WPCentral ones surely mean nothing. Keep that blindfold on, you poor thing :)
    Thanked by:
    FinancialP likes this.
  23. WanderingTraveler's Avatar

    Posts
    4,802 Posts
    Global Posts
    4,812 Global Posts
    PIN
    Email
    #23  
    Quote Originally Posted by AngryNil View Post
    Oh, okay. You chose arbitrary restrictions that you will defend until Microsoft reverses them, then you'll be all for it suddenly. I chose a flawed but exciting platform in my Omnia 7. I stayed with the flawed but exciting with my 8X purchase this year. But sure, I'm an Android user based off a few posts on AndroidCentral. Nice deduction, these 1500 WPCentral ones surely mean nothing. Keep that blindfold on, you poor thing :)
    Wait a minute. I could have sworn I saw you somewhere else. I'm pretty sure it was in the comments section of another site (The Verge?), and I'm pretty sure he fired out level-headed comments.
    He isn't some fanboy, I can tell you that.

    As for NFC, here's a sad part of the story.

    As you may or may not know, Nokia has been an avid proponent of NFC.
    From the Nokia C7-00 (first phone with NFC?) to shoehorning NFC onto the Lumia 610 to putting NFC into every WP8 Lumia, save for the 52x line, with accessories that have it.

    Great. Somewhere along the way, they ended up with Windows Phone. They ended up losing two things:
    1. Qt
    2. A platform that currently supports NFC to its fullest potential.

    I'm just hoping Microsoft implements some of the suggestions in this thread.
    Reviver of Forum Games! I'm TheWPCTraveler over on Nintendo Life, as well. You'll also find me over at gamrConnect as well, because I like numbers.

    3DS Friend Code: 1779-1560-3109 | NNID: TheWPCTraveler
    Devices: Lumia 630, ASUS T100, Nintendo 3DS XL.
    Now Playing: Conception II: Children of the Seven Stars [3DS]
    Now Watching: Pom Poko (平成狸合戦ぽんぽこ)


    I have a creepy avatar, don't I?
    Thanked by:
    FinancialP likes this.
  24. #24  
    Quote Originally Posted by WanderingTraveler View Post
    Wait a minute. I could have sworn I saw you somewhere else. I'm pretty sure it was in the comments section of another site (The Verge?), and I'm pretty sure he fired out level-headed comments.
    He isn't some fanboy, I can tell you that.
    Thanks, WT. I'm sure there's a reason that he chose to include Angry in his username.
    - Rich


    WPCentral.com | WPCentral Store | Mobile Nations Forum Rules

    Join Bing Rewards and get rewarded - and get me a few bonus points!
  25. AngryNil's Avatar
    Member

    Posts
    1,382 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,387 Global Posts
    #25  
    Quote Originally Posted by WanderingTraveler View Post
    He isn't some fanboy, I can tell you that.
    Really? Someone who legitimately stood behind a point for believable reason can argue the facts. He went straight for my credibility. He didn't stop at one baseless assertion, he even felt the need to back it up, following some terribly broken logic that led him to search up my four or so AndroidCentral posts. That's just blind - to people, to logic, to reality. I find it hard to believe that extent of irrationality displayed here could ever come out of a level-headed person.

    Quote Originally Posted by hopmedic View Post
    I'm sure there's a reason that he chose to include Angry in his username.
    You, sir, need medical help. (Oh, look how awfully clever that was!)
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-01-2014, 04:25 AM
  2. Replies: 3
    Last Post: 12-06-2013, 10:13 PM
  3. Windows Smartphone ASP Is Plunging In 3Q 2013
    By bryantest in forum Windows Phone 8
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 10-21-2013, 11:31 PM
  4. What is Pepper?
    By Dave Blake in forum Windows Phone Apps
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 08-27-2013, 04:34 AM
  5. Phone freezed. Not working
    By Manoj1551 in forum Nokia Lumia 1020
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 08-20-2013, 09:12 PM

Posting Permissions