- 08-13-2012, 11:11 AM #1
So I'm curious why certain posters here with violent, abusive predilections are allowed to continue to post? I'm not going to name any names, but you all know who I'm talking about, which should tell you everything you need to know. Can someone clarify the policy? Because anyone who threatens physical harm, up to and including death threats (which I have received from this poster), should not be a welcome member of a community. They should be a persona non grata.
- 08-13-2012, 11:53 AM #2
Have you reports the post? Please do report any offensive posts.
General statement to the community;
We can't be everywhere but we will respond to all reported posts. How we handel an issue with an individual member of these forums will never be made public. Please don't ask for clarification on any issue not directly related to you. You will be disappointed with the response.
- 08-13-2012, 12:06 PM #3
I did report a post just today. And I don't want to make this personal, but I received a ban for a far inferior violation of the rules. The only difference being that I am not a blind fanboy (like that certain person) and actually dare to be critical of WP. Which in this community sometimes seems to be the biggest crime of all...
- 08-13-2012, 12:19 PM #5
His violent posts on the main page and forum are always deleted, so a mod sees them. Yet he's still here. It's great that they're deleted, but...
Windows Phone sees slight dip in U.S. Marketshare | wpcentral | Windows Phone News, Forums, and Reviews
By arrow22 on Thu, 12 Jul 2012 5:32 pm EDT
What's wrong with you? I saw your previous post before it got removed... To say something like that because of a joke involving technology is NOT ok. Go outside, breath fresh air, and get some perspective.
His violent posts get deleted and yet he stays. And just today his abusive posts end up quoted (and deleted) threatening violence.
- 08-13-2012, 12:27 PM #6
Also, very important - adherence to thorough and precisely defined forum rules. The Terms and conditions should be clearly defined and prominently propagated. I can't even find them here. I know they are somewhere, I've seen them, but I can't even easily find them again... And the mods need to push them a lot harder then they do, IMO. And all the other small things that make up a moderation of a great forum, like splitting threads, making sure proper thread names are used (thread titles like "I Need Your Help !!!!" have little value) and all that jazz...
- 08-13-2012, 12:33 PM #7
A few things. First the front page comments are handled differently than the forums. More remove the post than discipline the member thats just the way it is. Next see my previous post please review. Lastly never compare your situation with someone else YOU don't have all the facts and on these forums YOU wont get them.
This thread will remain open as long as the comments here in remain civil.
- 08-13-2012, 12:48 PM #8
Thanks you for your comments and suggestions. That was very helpfull.
The rules haven't been posted here because they weren't needed. I hate rules and I hate posting them even more. I guess because of a small minority here at WPC that must change I will get the official forums rules posted here as soon as I have time. I had hoped this community of a couple of hundred daily users could communicate with each other in a civil manner without a list of rules but because of one or two that insist on causing issues that changes. :@ Our forums is growing I guess this is just growing pains.
- 08-13-2012, 12:53 PM #9
I think at least in this case, we have all the facts that we need. tekhna brought up an issue that is apparent to anybody who frequents this forum. It's up to you to judge it. But you should also realize that your actions (or their lack of) affect us all. And some people might not want to continue to visit a board where favoritism is clearly an issue.
Also, this is not the only issue recently, there has been another one just today that I PMed you about. I don't want to discuss that one here, just pointing out that these kind of issues keep increasing.
- 08-13-2012, 01:06 PM #10
- 08-13-2012, 01:52 PM #11
I don't think it's about favoritism, I just think that the behavior of this particular poster should be a zero-tolerance thing, and it's a bit unsettling that it's not. Flame fests, trolls, arguments, they all happen, but threats are on another level that, in my opinion, should not be tolerated, period. I won't tell mods how to do their job, but I will say that this poster's behavior is disturbing and seriously adversely affects this community. The fact that no one has said his name, and we all know it is speaks volumes.
- 08-13-2012, 10:42 PM #13
- 08-13-2012, 11:04 PM #14
I really think its just a few select individuals that are causing issues. Any ways your forum rules are now posted... :dry
- 08-14-2012, 12:16 AM #15
Hmm. I really need to calm. Down. But I really can't handle people saying mean stuff about ms. Not fair. I'm trying to but this mean stuff here is really ticking me of. Also I suffer from anger problems so you guys will understand what I'm goin through :)
- 08-14-2012, 12:26 AM #16
I think I second Danny. I have seen It too..I may have just joined a while back, but I have see some really strong words exchanged for something as petty as phone features. Its bizarre. Plz mods, I love this place, but these people, whoever they are and wherever they come from need to be civilized and controlled.
I am on other communities as well and the same arguments happen their too, albeit politely and peacefully.
PS: I love this place and I love WP8 two big reasons I'm here...
Sent from my RaZr Nexus.
- 08-14-2012, 01:30 PM #18
I will say it again the forums and the Blog are handled differently. The writers handle the comments in there threads along with Daniel. If a member of the Forums mod team sees something we might help out from time to time but that isn't our responsibility for the most part.
- 08-14-2012, 02:02 PM #19
We moderate comments quite regularly on the front page but a couple of things:
- We do have regular "trolls" who get banned, create new screen-names and comeback
- We implemented a new IP tracking and banning system, starting late last week, for front page comments
- A lot of you don't help by replying back to these low-lifes. Seriously, you aren't helping when you respond back. Just ignore them and email us.
- We barely get any reports or complaints about comments, so once again, if you see something, say something
- "I'm not going to name any names, but you all know who I'm talking about" No, we don't. Name names or stop complaining. The only thing weaker than troll commentors is a community of users who refuse to bring attention to those in charge.
While we want this to be a friendly community and have a vibrant discussion, the larger we get, the more troublemakers we're going to receive. That's just the internet.
We'll try to do what we can but we also need your help to not instigate trolls and to report things when you see them. As we upgrade the CMS system in the next few weeks, users should have better tools for reporting comments directly and even hopefully downvoting.
Finally, for all the attention this may get we honestly don't have many complaints. Maybe...maybe I get one email a week on this topic, so let's keep this in perspective.
- 08-14-2012, 04:22 PM #20
Daniel said "Just ignore them and email us."
That is how we name names we don't call out people in open forum. For those who don't know how to do that use the contact link at the top of every page.
We have a report button on every post in the forum its the little clipboard on the bottom left of this post with the "!" on it.
- 08-14-2012, 09:43 PM #22
seems infractions are commonly given out to anything that isn't vapid fanboyism...
Yo should see some of the infractions I've gotten while other people telling me that want me to die have nothing sad to them.
I think as long as you give only praise to wp7 pretty much anything goes
- 08-14-2012, 10:36 PM #23
Its funny to me how the people who get in trouble for braking the rules are always the ones who are complaining the most about them and how they are enforces. If those members want to hide behind the word fanboyism thats fine. In my opinion those members need to get some perspective. IMHO
- 08-14-2012, 10:50 PM #24
I do hope the moderators here know must of us post just out of enjoyment of mobile. I will be dead honest: I read about 15 sites off and on for mobile and only post on two. I will not be a part of a community that has the type of posters who attack others because:
1) They somehow have their self-worth wrapped up with an OS (I don't get that at all, and I loves me some WP).
2)This is where they come to vent their anger at the world.
The other site I post at is becoming a tad upsetting to me, and I may just move on. But I would be sorely bummed if I lost WP Central. This is a small community, but it is a good one. I am not at all worried about trolling over mobile. I could care less if Android/iOS/RIM fans troll here. That is a good sign for the growth of WP. Besides, a good troll is fun.
The other two types I listed would make me leave.
For now, I appreciate our moderators and our community.A closed mouth gathers no feet.
- 08-14-2012, 10:55 PM #25
Last edited by Preluva; 08-14-2012 at 11:01 PM.