Who cares if Samsung "makes you buy the dock separately" if the combined price of slate+dock is lower than HP's combined price of slate+dock? Bundling the dock instead of making it optional doesn't make a difference either way, in my opinion.
I like the build quality. Looks muuuuuuuch nicer than the Samsung Ativ Smart PC from an aesthetic perspective. But there's things I didn't like about it:
(1) Delayed availability (December instead of October like most competitors).
(2) No ports on the slate (all USB ports etc are on the dock).
(3) Headphone jack on the bottom of the slate means it won't sit comfortably on an exercise machine's tray, etc when headphones are plugged in. Mind-boggling placement for a multimedia tablet.
(4) No storage silo for the stylus, unlike the Thinkpad Tablet 2 and the Samsung Ativ Smart PC.