I actually like the ones from Verizon. As for the OtterBox, I had one (sold on ebay because I wanted less bulk - now using Trident Aegis), but even with the OtterBox, I put a screen protector on the phone. With the hole at the top for the speaker, there is the possibility of something getting in between the screen and the OtterBox's screen protector, and I didn't want to risk something getting in there and scratching the phone. The screen's sensitivity didn't suffer at all.