1jaxstate1
New member
I disagree. It's not that simple. I like how they separate certain factors. I see battery life is a 8. Battery life is important to me. Ecosystem is at a 5, well I don't really give a crap about that, so that's a trade off. Reception is a 7, seems kinda low, I thought Nokia phones were know for having great reception, I may be thinking about RIM phones. For me, I could remove the ecosystem score, or whatever scores I'm not interested or care for,and get a solid number off that.
Saying to should someone buy the phone in a simple Yes or No, mean you really have to know what the person wants or interested in.
Saying to should someone buy the phone in a simple Yes or No, mean you really have to know what the person wants or interested in.
The way I look at it, the review was good. Sure there were a 'unfair' jabs at the 920, but on the whole it was quite positive. I still think review sites should just do away with numbering systems. Stick to what Engadget, Joystiq, and Kotaku do. Write a review and then in the wrap-up write the pros and cons.
If it was just 'the words' and no arbitrary numbering system it would've been great.
I still love the Kotaku format - Should I buy this or not? Yes or no?