I'm very frustrated and I just need somewhere to vent. I had a few WP7 devices (Focus, Radar, 710), and only used them a couple months at a time. They weren't my primary device, but I was really interested in the OS. I had decided that when WP8 rolled around, I'd seriously consider it as my daily driver. But sadly, that is not to be...
I bought a Lumia 920 on day one, off-contract, unsubsidized, from a Microsoft Store. I then contacted AT&T (I'm very new to using AT&T as a service provider) about getting it unlocked. I explained that I had no intentions of leaving AT&T, I just like to have unlocked phones for when I travel. I also wouldn't have LTE on any other GSM carrier in the US. But, I was informed that the 920 was an "AT&T Exclusive," and as such is not and would never be eligible for unlock (at least not any time soon).
Well this was shocking to me...after all, I bought it with no contract, not even through AT&T at all! I was told that the reason was due to contractual obligations. Another shocker! I asked what they meant by that, since I did not buy with a contract. No, no, I was told, contractual obligations between Microsoft, Nokia, and AT&T. As you can imagine, I almost lost it. The notion that I, having spent $500+ for my phone, did not actually own my phone is infuriating. Not only that, but I was also advised by AT&T that any attempt to find and use unlock codes from eBay or other web services was illegal.
-as a side note, in my opinion, how I had been treated and how I had been advised by AT&T should actually BE criminal behavior-
What really gets me is that I really, really like the 920. But, in the spirit of compromise, I thought I'd give the 8X a shot. I thought, well since it's not an "AT&T exclusive" (btw if anyone says those words to me in person, it will take all that I have not to punch them in the throat), there's no reason why AT&T won't unlock it! Short answer: I was wrong.
You see, AT&T regards unlock requests as a privilege that they have every right to withhold. Even if I buy off-contract, the reps tell me, unlocks may not be available. Why? I ask. Well, they respond, it's up to the manufacturer to provide the code. LIE. HOW DO THEY GET AWAY WITH SUCH BLATANT LIES?!
At this point, I've given up on AT&T ever having my business again. So I think, well what about T-Mobile? They're more consumer friendly, more rational a carrier. Again, short answer, no. I call T-Mobile and they tell me they won't even sell me an 8X without a contract (what?!). I look online, and the no-commitment price is $600 ($150 more than AT&T's off-contract price)...so that's a no.
Now, some might say I can look at importers like Expansys, buy "unlocked" from eBay, or even try the T-Mo 8X off-contract and hope they'll unlock it. I'm sorry, but no. All of these options will cost me over $600 on the low end and upwards of $800 on the high end. When the competition is a Nexus 4 that comes unlocked, off-contract, and pentaband for $299, I cannot in good conscience pursue any of those options. ****, even Apple will sell me an unlocked iPhone 5 soon for $500. This is not even mentioning the fact that it SHOULD NOT be this hard for someone to spend $500 on a phone and expect to actually own it.
The carriers are poisoning the Windows Phone experience for me and it's a shame. Maybe I'll grab one up when (and if) either the 920 or 8X is available unlocked, maybe I won't. Microsoft needs to take a cue from Google and Apple and offer its wares unlocked, direct to consumer via it's own Microsoft stores (brick and mortar as well as online). Until then, I'm gone.
(Oh, and I will not go to a CDMA carrier. I think the reason should be self-evident.)
I bought a Lumia 920 on day one, off-contract, unsubsidized, from a Microsoft Store. I then contacted AT&T (I'm very new to using AT&T as a service provider) about getting it unlocked. I explained that I had no intentions of leaving AT&T, I just like to have unlocked phones for when I travel. I also wouldn't have LTE on any other GSM carrier in the US. But, I was informed that the 920 was an "AT&T Exclusive," and as such is not and would never be eligible for unlock (at least not any time soon).
Well this was shocking to me...after all, I bought it with no contract, not even through AT&T at all! I was told that the reason was due to contractual obligations. Another shocker! I asked what they meant by that, since I did not buy with a contract. No, no, I was told, contractual obligations between Microsoft, Nokia, and AT&T. As you can imagine, I almost lost it. The notion that I, having spent $500+ for my phone, did not actually own my phone is infuriating. Not only that, but I was also advised by AT&T that any attempt to find and use unlock codes from eBay or other web services was illegal.
-as a side note, in my opinion, how I had been treated and how I had been advised by AT&T should actually BE criminal behavior-
What really gets me is that I really, really like the 920. But, in the spirit of compromise, I thought I'd give the 8X a shot. I thought, well since it's not an "AT&T exclusive" (btw if anyone says those words to me in person, it will take all that I have not to punch them in the throat), there's no reason why AT&T won't unlock it! Short answer: I was wrong.
You see, AT&T regards unlock requests as a privilege that they have every right to withhold. Even if I buy off-contract, the reps tell me, unlocks may not be available. Why? I ask. Well, they respond, it's up to the manufacturer to provide the code. LIE. HOW DO THEY GET AWAY WITH SUCH BLATANT LIES?!
At this point, I've given up on AT&T ever having my business again. So I think, well what about T-Mobile? They're more consumer friendly, more rational a carrier. Again, short answer, no. I call T-Mobile and they tell me they won't even sell me an 8X without a contract (what?!). I look online, and the no-commitment price is $600 ($150 more than AT&T's off-contract price)...so that's a no.
Now, some might say I can look at importers like Expansys, buy "unlocked" from eBay, or even try the T-Mo 8X off-contract and hope they'll unlock it. I'm sorry, but no. All of these options will cost me over $600 on the low end and upwards of $800 on the high end. When the competition is a Nexus 4 that comes unlocked, off-contract, and pentaband for $299, I cannot in good conscience pursue any of those options. ****, even Apple will sell me an unlocked iPhone 5 soon for $500. This is not even mentioning the fact that it SHOULD NOT be this hard for someone to spend $500 on a phone and expect to actually own it.
The carriers are poisoning the Windows Phone experience for me and it's a shame. Maybe I'll grab one up when (and if) either the 920 or 8X is available unlocked, maybe I won't. Microsoft needs to take a cue from Google and Apple and offer its wares unlocked, direct to consumer via it's own Microsoft stores (brick and mortar as well as online). Until then, I'm gone.
(Oh, and I will not go to a CDMA carrier. I think the reason should be self-evident.)