Video Editing on WP 8.1 ?

[Rickosw]

Hi Guys,

So video editing on the phone with WP 8.1 still unavailable?
can anyone confirm / advice?

​cheers!

 

[anon(7900571)]

developers have to use new API to develop video editing apps for windows phone 8.1.

 

[anon(7900571)]

let windows phone 8.1 roll out and you will definitely see many video editing apps including slow motion recording\converting

 

[Oliverspin]

Slow motion will be a great addition! Phones will need higher fps recording in the future to really take advantage of it though.

 

[Rickosw]

hi guys, thanks for your reply!

 

[Yazan Abdullah]

dude with all honesty u r delusional. neither MS nor Nokia is capable of developing a usable, intuitive, and reliable video-editing app.
think about it: if they could have, they would have done so by now, no? you'd think that MS and Nokia, with their photography pitch, would have video editing since wp8.
Nokia developed video trimmer, which is unintuitive and useless because it does not remove midsegments of the video you're editing.

now MS has given up, so they are allowing 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps. and we all know what's gonna happen: 3d party devs will produce a whole bunch of apps and sell them for 3$ each. you buy and use the app for a few mins and you'll be like "oh cool...this looks intuitive and UI is awesome...oh look 10 different effects I can add to my vid wohoo".......but then when you actually try to use the app to actually edit your video from your beach trip, you realize that the app does not work or is crashing. is that not what happens with browser and youtube apps? we use'em for a few days, and then revert to native apps as we figure out the crazy bugs in these 3'd party apps.

also.... is it just me, or is everyone shocked that MS has only NOW STARTED to allow 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps? why was that not allowed 18 months ago? I just can't wrap my head around it. if you are not capable of making it, why not allow 3d party devs from the beginning? now we have to wait 18 months for a dev to make a decent app.

good luck using the vid-editing garbage that's gunna be sold at 2$ a pop just 2 months after 8.1 rolls out. you'll see all these mediocre vid-editing apps come out and earn 5 star ratings on the windows store from people who rate before they actually use the app. don't be fooled. if you got an extra 2$, i'd give em to charity instead.

 

[Coolaaron88]

dude with all honesty u r delusional. neither MS nor Nokia is capable of developing a usable, intuitive, and reliable video-editing app.
think about it: if they could have, they would have done so by now, no? you'd think that MS and Nokia, with their photography pitch, would have video editing since wp8.
Nokia developed video trimmer, which is unintuitive and useless because it does not remove midsegments of the video you're editing.

now MS has given up, so they are allowing 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps. and we all know what's gonna happen: 3d party devs will produce a whole bunch of apps and sell them for 3$ each. you buy and use the app for a few mins and you'll be like "oh cool...this looks intuitive and UI is awesome...oh look 10 different effects I can add to my vid wohoo".......but then when you actually try to use the app to actually edit your video from your beach trip, you realize that the app does not work or is crashing. is that not what happens with browser and youtube apps? we use'em for a few days, and then revert to native apps as we figure out the crazy bugs in these 3'd party apps.

also.... is it just me, or is everyone shocked that MS has only NOW STARTED to allow 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps? why was that not allowed 18 months ago? I just can't wrap my head around it. if you are not capable of making it, why not allow 3d party devs from the beginning? now we have to wait 18 months for a dev to make a decent app.

good luck using the vid-editing garbage that's gunna be sold at 2$ a pop just 2 months after 8.1 rolls out. you'll see all these mediocre vid-editing apps come out and earn 5 star ratings on the windows store from people who rate before they actually use the app. don't be fooled. if you got an extra 2$, i'd give em to charity instead.

You seem really angry. You should have a Snickers.

 

[smoledman]

I really wonder about the robustness of the OS core. I mean think about it, iOS has had video editing since 2010 and here are in 2014 and no video editing on Windows Phone.

 

[Yazan Abdullah]

I really wonder about the robustness of the OS core. I mean think about it, iOS has had video editing since 2010 and here are in 2014 and no video editing on Windows Phone.

yup..that's my point. I am not angry. I am just in shock and awe. ....and I honestly think that they're incapable of doing it effectively. that is the only explanation. you see apple perfected all things related to image gallery, graphics, and media, from the get go. the flurry screen saver is still something that MS can never accomplish. same can be said about the image gallery in iPAD and off course the very intuitive video editing app in iOS.

 

[bayanii]

yup..that's my point. I am not angry. I am just in shock and awe. ....and I honestly think that they're incapable of doing it effectively. that is the only explanation. you see apple perfected all things related to image gallery, graphics, and media, from the get go. the flurry screen saver is still something that MS can never accomplish. same can be said about the image gallery in iPAD and off course the very intuitive video editing app in iOS.

Agreed. I'd rather have them not release anything than put out garbage.

 

[bayanii]

dude with all honesty u r delusional. neither MS nor Nokia is capable of developing a usable, intuitive, and reliable video-editing app.
think about it: if they could have, they would have done so by now, no? you'd think that MS and Nokia, with their photography pitch, would have video editing since wp8.
Nokia developed video trimmer, which is unintuitive and useless because it does not remove midsegments of the video you're editing.

now MS has given up, so they are allowing 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps. and we all know what's gonna happen: 3d party devs will produce a whole bunch of apps and sell them for 3$ each. you buy and use the app for a few mins and you'll be like "oh cool...this looks intuitive and UI is awesome...oh look 10 different effects I can add to my vid wohoo".......but then when you actually try to use the app to actually edit your video from your beach trip, you realize that the app does not work or is crashing. is that not what happens with browser and youtube apps? we use'em for a few days, and then revert to native apps as we figure out the crazy bugs in these 3'd party apps.

also.... is it just me, or is everyone shocked that MS has only NOW STARTED to allow 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps? why was that not allowed 18 months ago? I just can't wrap my head around it. if you are not capable of making it, why not allow 3d party devs from the beginning? now we have to wait 18 months for a dev to make a decent app.

good luck using the vid-editing garbage that's gunna be sold at 2$ a pop just 2 months after 8.1 rolls out. you'll see all these mediocre vid-editing apps come out and earn 5 star ratings on the windows store from people who rate before they actually use the app. don't be fooled. if you got an extra 2$, i'd give em to charity instead.

Not ccompletely true about 3rd party apps. There are plenty, not all, that are equivalent or even better than official apps. Video editing is a great tool, but not everyone needs it. Its 2 dollars! Its the price of a candy bar or a Gatorade. Chill fellow Windows user. Support the people who make an effort to help out the community. Can you develop a video editing app? If so, you have my apologies.

 

[smoledman]

Not ccompletely true about 3rd party apps. There are plenty, not all, that are equivalent or even better than official apps. Video editing is a great tool, but not everyone needs it. Its 2 dollars! Its the price of a candy bar or a Gatorade. Chill fellow Windows user. Support the people who make an effort to help out the community. Can you develop a video editing app? If so, you have my apologies.

​No the real question is why hasn't Microsoft come out with an iMovie equivalent for Windows Phone and Windows 8.X?

 

[radmanvr]

@Yazan Abdullah So basically, what you are saying is 3rd party apps suck? If so what do you think of Rudy Huyn's apps?

If not, then you are saying 3rd party apps for specifically video editing will suck but what if Rudy makes one then what? Will it suck still?

I agree with you though that Microsoft just started to open up to devs to make a video editing app but I do not agree that they tried to make one and failed then decided to open it up to devs. The whole thing sounds to /tinfoilish

Anywho, to me its going to be a race to see which dev can put out the best video editing app because the person that does will make the big bucks so the reward is high so I believe this will make devs want to work hard at it and make it robust.

 

[Christian Holmstedt]

dude with all honesty u r delusional. neither MS nor Nokia is capable of developing a usable, intuitive, and reliable video-editing app.
think about it: if they could have, they would have done so by now, no? you'd think that MS and Nokia, with their photography pitch, would have video editing since wp8.
Nokia developed video trimmer, which is unintuitive and useless because it does not remove midsegments of the video you're editing.

now MS has given up, so they are allowing 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps. and we all know what's gonna happen: 3d party devs will produce a whole bunch of apps and sell them for 3$ each. you buy and use the app for a few mins and you'll be like "oh cool...this looks intuitive and UI is awesome...oh look 10 different effects I can add to my vid wohoo".......but then when you actually try to use the app to actually edit your video from your beach trip, you realize that the app does not work or is crashing. is that not what happens with browser and youtube apps? we use'em for a few days, and then revert to native apps as we figure out the crazy bugs in these 3'd party apps.

also.... is it just me, or is everyone shocked that MS has only NOW STARTED to allow 3d party devs to make vid-editing apps? why was that not allowed 18 months ago? I just can't wrap my head around it. if you are not capable of making it, why not allow 3d party devs from the beginning? now we have to wait 18 months for a dev to make a decent app.

good luck using the vid-editing garbage that's gunna be sold at 2$ a pop just 2 months after 8.1 rolls out. you'll see all these mediocre vid-editing apps come out and earn 5 star ratings on the windows store from people who rate before they actually use the app. don't be fooled. if you got an extra 2$, i'd give em to charity instead.

Woah, they will sell a video editing app for $2! What a disgrace, the world will end. Hold on a second, my $2 bottle of water is empty. Gotta buy another one then I'll finish commenting on this post.

 

[Yazan Abdullah]

Woah, they will sell a video editing app for $2! What a disgrace, the world will end. Hold on a second, my $2 bottle of water is empty. Gotta buy another one then I'll finish commenting on this post.

no...2 bucks is no biggie...but charging more than android and ios prices for inferior apps is lame

 

[Yazan Abdullah]

@Yazan Abdullah So basically, what you are saying is 3rd party apps suck? If so what do you think of Rudy Huyn's apps?

If not, then you are saying 3rd party apps for specifically video editing will suck but what if Rudy makes one then what? Will it suck still?

I agree with you though that Microsoft just started to open up to devs to make a video editing app but I do not agree that they tried to make one and failed then decided to open it up to devs. The whole thing sounds to /tinfoilish

Anywho, to me its going to be a race to see which dev can put out the best video editing app because the person that does will make the big bucks so the reward is high so I believe this will make devs want to work hard at it and make it robust.

not gonna happen my friend. MS has to develop the video editing app just like how it also needs to develop a youtube app. 3 party apps are okay but the real stuff has to come out of MS.

 

[Wyn6]

no...2 bucks is no biggie...but charging more than android and ios prices for inferior apps is lame

Ah! Could you link me to the inferior video editing apps? I'd like to take a gander at these loathsome pieces of coding transgression.

 

[LillWicke]

3 party apps are okay but the real stuff has to come out of MS.

Why? I don't get this.

 

[jongthechemist]

If you have time, you can watch this session on video editing APIs in WP8.1. The app made by Microsoft engineers is quite decent except for the UI. Don't be too paranoid. It's easy for developers to create these apps as you can see in the video.

Video: The New Video Editing APIs for Windows Phone: Windows.Media.Editing | Build 2014 | Channel 9
API Doc: Windows.Media.Editing namespace (Windows)

 

[psychotron]

yup..that's my point. I am not angry. I am just in shock and awe. ....and I honestly think that they're incapable of doing it effectively. that is the only explanation. you see apple perfected all things related to image gallery, graphics, and media, from the get go. the flurry screen saver is still something that MS can never accomplish. same can be said about the image gallery in iPAD and off course the very intuitive video editing app in iOS.

Hate to break this to you, but Apple didn't "perfect" anything to do with video from the get go. It wasn't available until the 3gs. The first couple of iPhone models weren't even capable of taking video, so there was nothing to edit. And when it finally did include an editor most people bought third party apps because the built in one was too limited.