Sorry, but even though I agree the author could've pointed out that living images was indeed an innovation introduced by Nokia before Apple came up with the same, the overall review is ok. He's not lying anywhere as far as I can see. The phone is having a couple of issues - mostly firmware related stuff that should be easy to fix through updates. And Windows 10 mobile is definitely NOT ready for consumers. It is still in beta stage, admitted that it has gotten a lot better than those builds delivers through the Insider program 2 or 3 months ago.
Don't get me wrong, I've been a loyal WP user for 5 years now and a Windows Mobile user before that. And I even ordered a 950XL which should arrive today or tomorrow. But I've been well aware of what I was going to buy into. I knew about the issues of the phone and those of Windows 10 mobile. So that's no deal breaker for me. But for the majority of people out there who willingly shell out a couple hundred bucks, it indeed IS an issue. They expect a fully functioning device with a matured OS running on it. And that's just not the case as of yet.
I think this review was mostly fair. Maybe that guy should've trained Windows Hello a little better and see if that changed how reliably and fast it works, but he even pointed out he didn't waste much time training it. Which is what many people out there will probably do.