I think if only one review or two reviews are mediocre, maybe the reviewer is biased or they valued too much for the feature that is not the strength yet. But if most of them are mediocre, it triggers some reflection on 928 manufacturer (Nokia and MS).
I recently reviewed several phones within the past 2 months : HTC-One, Blackberry Z10, Galaxy S4, Nokia Lumia 928. And my daily driver is Galaxy Note 2. The verdict? Those new phones all have their imperfection that some are good to have if you have a cheap upgrade, some are NOT worth it to jump ship, let alone jump carrier or OS.
HTC One , the one earning most media buzz and seems to be Verge and Android Central's favorite, really failed at battery department for me. I have NO idea in the age of 1080p and LTE, why manufacturers still pack any battery less than 3000 mAH in their phone, and for HTC , it is worse, why they make it non-swappable. For the design. I get it. But as a daily driver, design wears out when you have a few dents or scratches, or even you have a phone case on it, the real deal is the ability to accomplish things to make your life easier and better. A battery dead phone is not making life easier.
Galaxy S4, really boring stuff all over again. If I have an S3, I failed to see why I need to jump to S4, unless I have a 2-year upgrade and get the S4 at deeply discounted price, to accept the question: "oh , did you clean up your S3? it looks so new!"
Z10, as a new comer, the OS still has a long way to go. And the battery sucks big time.
928 is the closest one to convince me that I can live with both GNote 2 and 928. It is beautiful, sleek and it gives refreshing feeling from a new ecosystem. Its battery, though only 2000 mAH, is really amazing so I guess the software must be very very efficient, unlike those in Samsung phones...
Catches on 928?
Microsoft is some kind of deal breaker. Their attitude towards such product is not inspiring. I fully respect Nokia's contribution to this game, their hardware and their exclusive apps are really amazing. While MS, as the OS provider, is too blind or deaf to customer's voices. Their OS now is lagging Android a bit more every day. Not enough fast and quick innovation coming to this platform. I feel like while Android has thousands of developers contributing to the platform everyday, WP has Nokia as third party that makes the biggest contribution and locked-down apps, too little, too slow. After watching the Google IO, I still feel that the gap is widening, not narrowing.
Imagine in the ideal world, Nokia makes an Android phone. Oh my...