1. RumoredNow's Avatar
    * If you are concerned about unlocking phones in the United States and if it is legal... Click Here.
    * For lists of mvno (airtime reseller) networks and supplemental details... Click Here.
    __________

    Everyone wants the best phone, the best service and the best price. Sometimes that means we sacrifice one for the other. But what if you could have it all? Maybe you can... A huge part of what holds users back from buying an unlocked phone is fear of incompatibility with their carrier. Or some may not switch to another carrier because it doesn't offer the phone they want.

    Let's try and break it down in parts for users to understand what they need to know and where to go to find that info.

    Two Worlds That Don't Mix

    There are two types of cellular system in use: CDMA and GSM.

    CDMA or Code Division Multiple Access is a model most prevalent in the United States and includes Verizon and Sprint carriers. It is basically a carrier side authorization. It is based on IMEI and your phone passes a check on that IMEI (International Mobile Equipment Identity) to gain access to the network. CDMA does not require a SIM card to gain network access. CDMA companies seem to mostly be country by country with some primarily GSM companies dabbling in CDMA on a regional basis.

    GSM or Global System for Mobile is a user side authorization where your access to the network is programmed on a SIM card. GSM is by far the more prevalent system around the world, although many countries have carriers of each type. In the US, GSM is exemplified by AT&T or T-Mobile. Vodaphone, Orange, MovieStar, and T-Mobile are all major players around the world and recognizable by most users as SIM enabled networks.

    Because of the two different systems, the two types of phones do not cross over between networks type well or at all. Some CDMA phones do have SIM slots, but mostly that is for international travel and the SIM probably will not authenticate all of the radios on board (more on that later). Because CDMA phones are "built for a network" most CDMA operators will not authenticate a phone that has not been branded to their service. Some CDMA airtime resellers will do so, but that seems more an exception than a rule.

    In general, any branded phone (bearing a carrier name on its case) is locked to that network and designed to access that network efficiently. CDMA phones, generally speaking, are not easily transferable from one carrier's service to another. <edit: this list shows that more mvno networks in the US now allow you to bring a branded, carrier unlocked CDMA device to their service.> Branded GSM phones need to be SIM Unlocked to transfer and then will only find a good match on another GSM service. Factory Unlocked phones were never branded to a carrier and work with any SIM that accesses the right radio frequencies.

    If you want to run unlocked, Factory Unlocked provides the most choices and ease of use. Factory Unlocked GSM phones usually have more frequencies on their radios. They are meant to be "plug and play." SIM Unlocked GSM phones may work well too... So long as you do your homework and get the right match of phone and carrier. Read on for how to research this very issue.

    What's the Frequency, Kenneth?

    Moderator Laura Knotek wisely advises, 'Pick Your Network First.' Sound advice. As she puts it, the best phone in the world doesn't do you any good if you have lousy service. Find a carrier with good coverage in the areas where you live, work and travel to frequently. One that has the price you are willing to pay for the features you need. Got it? Good.

    Take a look at these tables: Mobile country code - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    You can look up your country and carrier to see what type of network they have and what frequencies they need to see on your phone. (Or to literally SEE your phone!) Generally speaking; GSM will refer to 2G radio frequencies and UMTS and WCDMA will represent 3G radio frequencies. You don't need to, but you can, visit this link or this link to read more on the evolution of network protocols. So from the wiki table, jot down some notes on your preferred network and what 2G/3G radios you need. Pay attention to multiple entries. Most often you need two channels (separate frequencies) - one for uplink and one for downlink. Some entries also note LTE frequencies, some do not.

    No worries, here are tables for LTE by country/carrier and showing Bands and Frequencies needed: List of LTE networks - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    Take some more notes on what LTE radio is needed for your carrier choice.

    For your carrier choice in your country you are going to need to know the 2G or GSM frequencies they use, the 3G or UMTS/WCDMA frequencies and the LTE Frequencies and Bands. Only by assuring your equipment matches this need will you find a great match that yields the fastest data available at whatever location you find yourself.

    If the carrier you are interested in does not appear on the tables linked above; it most likely is a mvno or Mobile Virtual Network Operator - a reseller of airtime on a major player's Towers. You can usually find out who's Towers they link to by a simple web search for "what towers does <carrier name> use" and plugging the answer back into the tables.

    Say That Again

    Here's an example:
    I live in Ireland and I like Vodafone. My mates are all on Vodafone. We like the giant size of the company and the way they span the EU. We feel like we can get a service we know and understand when we travel throughout the EU with their "connect abroad" feature.

    On the 2G/3G wiki table (Mobile country code - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia) it looks like this:
    capture.png

    On the LTE wiki table (List of LTE networks - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia) it looks like this:
    capture02.png

    So I need:
    2G radio with 900/1800 MHz
    3G radio with 2100 MHz
    LTE radio with 800 MHz on Band 20

    But wait... There's only one frequency listed for 3G. That means it is only the downlink channel (since that gets the most traffic). If I can't uplink my requests, I won't be able to download my data. So I look here: UMTS frequency bands - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    capture03.png

    For the LTE just make sure to match the Band. LTE uplink/downlink are often much closer in spectrum than 3G. If you want to know more you can look at this link.

    So now I know I need:
    2G radio with 900/1800 MHz
    3G radio with 1900/2100 MHz
    LTE radio with 800 MHz on Band 20
    In order to have a phone run properly on Vodafone Ireland.

    ​Let's Go Shopping

    One thing I don't like about Vodafone IE is that they will not offer the 1520. I want a big honking phone and the 1520 is the biggest. I like that obnoxious yellow colour too. I just want to make sure it will work for me. I could run all over the internet searching for places that carry the 1520 and hope they show all the spec, but I also want another phone for my kid brother... Something rugged, tried and true, but older so I don't have to break the bank getting him a phone. I think a Lumia 925 would be about perfect for him. A good all-around phone.

    It's easier to go to one site where you can look at the specs from lots of phones and even compare them side by side. I like GSM arena for that. I can search phones by model name, see the full spec sheets and even compare phones head to head.

    capture04.png

    So my comparisons show me that for a 1520 to work on Vodafone Ireland it needs to be the RM-937 variant. A Bing search shows me the RM-937 is a Factory Unlocked model and it comes in yellow. I'm good there.

    For a 925 to work for my little brother on Voda it needs to be the RM-892 model. Bing brings me good news again! Another Factory Unlocked model.

    Find the carrier frequencies you need on each radio, match a phone up and look for an unlocked model. If a branded phone from another network has the right frequencies and the seller has SIM Unlocked it that will work as well...

    Some Precautions

    It's not always as smooth as the examples I've shown above. You may have to check a few models to find the right fit for your network choice. The more you use the tools I've linked, especially the phone look ups, the more familiar you become with the system. The easier it is to get match ups on the first and second try.

    When buying phones, check multiple sources to make sure you are getting a good deal and not over paying just to get the phone you want. Know the difference if buying new or used. If a used phone is refurbished, try and find out who did the refurbish - the OEM, a reputable reseller or Joe in his basement. Always check the reputation of where you are buying from if possible. Look at site and store reviews as well as the product reviews. Get to know the players in the market.

    If you are buying a carrier branded phone that is SIM Unlocked from an individual, try to estimate from the source of the ad how reputable the sellers are on that site. Check any user reviews. Ask to see a picture of the phone clearly showing it receives a service it is not branded to.

    If the person who owns the phone gets it unlocked from their carrier that is very helpful. Most carriers will NOT SIM Unlock a phone for you if you are not a customer of theirs. Let me repeat that. A Carrier Will NOT Unlock One Of Their Phones For A Non-Customer. Don't buy a carrier branded phone thinking you'll just get it unlocked by that carrier after you get it. You can try a 3rd party unlock service, but they have mixed track records. A lot depends on the service, the phone hardware and the OS. From what I can gather from user reviews; phone unlock services are a gamble at best. Most will refund you if their unlock fails, but what you really want is an unlocked phone ready to plug your SIM into and have it start working.

    I'll organize the links to the tools below. Please bookmark them so they are easy to find when you need them. Feel free to ask questions. There are a lot of savvy phone shoppers on this site. Someone will be glad to help out.

    HAPPY PHONE HUNTING!!!
    Last edited by RumoredNow; 12-17-2014 at 12:05 AM. Reason: added beginning text and hyperlink
    12-05-2014 05:40 PM
  2. RumoredNow's Avatar
    Am I Allowed To Carrier Unlock My Cell Phone In The USA?

    In recent years there has been some confusion about unlocking phones in the United States of America and popular media often touts that it is "illegal" for you to unlock a cell phone to use on a network other than the one which it was branded and sold to operate on. Using a carrier branded cell phone on another network in and of itself is perfectly legal, sanctioned and normal behavior that will not cause you any criminal or civil difficulty under the law. What is often reported on (and sometimes misquoted) is the actual unlocking process itself and how it relates to copyright protection of carrier firmware under the DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act).

    The DMCA regulates digital locking of copyrighted material. These locks protect creative media such as music, novels, photographic images, digital reproductions of original paintings, etc. against piracy or commercial profit from unauthorized copies of artistic and other types of work. Piracy bad! DMCA Good! I state it so simply because the regulations themselves are rather simple. One rule fits all sort of legalized jargon that is maintained, interpreted by and ruled upon by the Librarian of Congress. That's right, the Librarian. An august person who administers the Library of Congress. This person has in past issued exemptions for cell phone unlocking during 2006 and 2010 rulings.

    DMCA Bad?

    In 2013 the Librarian chose not to renew this exemption. The result? Carriers put the lock on the software to protect their copyrighted firmware. Carriers have final say as to whether or not the unlock is given. No one else. To be sure the penalty for unauthorized unlocking of a cell phone would be monetary damages awarded in a civil suite. You would have to be sued and loose. It would have to be proven that by unlocking a cell phone you hindered the plaintiff from collecting money due for the work being digitally locked and that you yourself benefited financially from such a breach of the lock. This enforcement would most likely never occur against an individual, but is technically possible. Those who have the most to fear from such a policy are the 3rd party unlock services that do in fact make money off of unlocking cell phones..

    In point of fact: carriers are actually obligated under the law to provide you with an unlock code when requested - if you meet certain criteria which amounts to your being a current or former customer in good standing. In other words you used their service and don't owe them money. They can not unfairly burden you from using another service. Carriers in the United States are very good about following this policy. Another point in favor of users is that legacy devices (those no longer being maintained by carriers) do not have the same restriction as new devices. The firmware is outdated and needs no protection. How long a phone needs to be unsupported is currently untested in legal courts.

    In any event, so as not to burden users from unfair blockage on their own personal property (their paid for cell phone [no unpaid subsidy balance]) the Librarian further ruled that if a carrier will not unlock a cell phone "within a reasonable time" and the user wants the unlock solely to put the phone on anther service, that user may seek an alternate means apart from the carrier in order to get a phone unlocked. What constitutes "reasonable time" is open to interpretation and has (so far as I know) not been tested in a court.

    <edit: It appears from information I've seen around the web that 6 months from end of service on a network may be the standard time frame a carrier can bar the unlock from happening. So if you skip out on your bill today, your phone will not get the unlock code for 6 months...>

    Congress Good?

    So previously there was no restriction on unlocking a cell phone. Or rather there was an exemption to existing copyright rules that allowed for it. That exemption was removed and in January of 2013 it became an unauthorized tampering of a digital lock (on "newer" devices) if you did not have carrier approval for the unlock.

    In 2014, Congress reinstated the exemption until such time as the Librarian of Congress could revisit the ruling. As of August 2014 any activity that was permissible before the 2013 ruling is permissible once more... In other words things are as they were before this craziness started.

    The Librarian of Congress will deliberate on the matter again sometime during 2015. Stay tuned.

    Links For More Reading:
    Current State: You Can Now Legally Unlock Your Cellphone, Here's What It Means for You
    Results of the 2013 Removal of the Exemption: Carrier-Unlocking Smartphones Will Be Illegal In The U.S. Tomorrow: Here's How (And If) It Affects You
    The "Roll Back" Action by The US Congress: Unlocking Consumer Choice and Wireless Competition Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    Last edited by RumoredNow; 04-10-2015 at 09:53 PM.
    12-09-2014 01:29 AM
  3. RichardBurt's Avatar
    With all of the dev updates the Nokia trick of ##3283 or ##3282# to access the field test has been disabled / changed.

    If anyone finds out the new code for field test then you can also enable / disable radio settings suitable for your carrier.

    EDIT: I have a 920 and it is disabled. Other phones (as pointed out by RumoredNow) may be different.
    RumoredNow likes this.
    12-09-2014 01:55 AM
  4. RumoredNow's Avatar
    With all of the dev updates the Nokia trick of ##3283 or ##3282# to access the field test has been disabled / changed.

    If anyone finds out the new code for field test then you can also enable / disable radio settings suitable for your carrier.
    That is a valuable trick to learn... And it is not disabled in some models yet. I'd definitely research that it CAN be done on a specific model before counting on it for a future phone.

    There is a How To Thread for enabling 1700 MHz WCDMA on the AT&T 1520 so when it is unlocked you can get T-Mo H+ in areas not refarmed to LTE. http://forums.windowscentral.com/nok...-4-1700-a.html
    Guytronic and a5cent like this.
    12-09-2014 02:01 AM
  5. RumoredNow's Avatar
    mvno stands for Mobile Virtual Network Operator, which means they have a service, but rely on someone else's towers for your connection. It may even be more than one of the established networks. The rise in mvno offerings is driven by competition. Some mvno services are actually a big, name brand carrier in a less fancy wrapper. Some are collaborations between retail stores and carriers. Others are simply companies that want to be in mobile and strike up deals with major carriers to avoid the astronomical cost of building a national network of cell towers. Bargain hunters and do-it-yourself types love mvno service for the lack of a contract, ease of changing providers and often times lower monthly cost of the service.

    Phones on an mvno are not subsidized so you pay for phones outright. The phones may be a bit older than newest release and seldom reach the top tier of spec. However, the fact that most mvno providers will let you BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) is a major draw, provides one of the best ways to pair the phone you want with great coverage and is completely within the scope of this thread.


    General Reading on mvno Networks:
    Mobile virtual network operator - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


    Lists of mvno Networks with Supplemental Details:
    Alphabetical List of mvno Networks - Wikipedia the free encyclopedia
    List of Australian mobile virtual network operators - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    List of Canadian mobile phone companies - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    List of Ireland mobile virtual network operators - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    List of United Kingdom mobile virtual network operators - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    List of United States mobile virtual network operators - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    Last edited by RumoredNow; 12-23-2014 at 10:40 AM. Reason: typo
    a5cent and Guytronic like this.
    12-16-2014 10:30 PM
  6. Kavu2's Avatar
    Great tip from Paul Thurrott's website...

    Will My Phone Work with a certain carrier (US or worldwide)....specs matchups search engine....

    WillMyPhoneWork.net - Check if your phone works on a network

    Enter your phone Brand, Model, Sub-Model(eg. current carrier/spec format)...then add new country loc and select a new carrier to see what bands(if any) your phone will work on with that new carrier in that new location(country)
    RumoredNow likes this.
    02-17-2015 10:37 AM
  7. RumoredNow's Avatar
    Great tip from Paul Thurrott's website...

    Will My Phone Work with a certain carrier (US or worldwide)....specs matchups search engine....

    WillMyPhoneWork.net - Check if your phone works on a network

    Enter your phone Brand, Model, Sub-Model(eg. current carrier/spec format)...then add new country loc and select a new carrier to see what bands(if any) your phone will work on with that new carrier in that new location(country)
    Thanks... I've been meaning to link that for a couple of days... I tested it out briefly and it seems of general help and accurate. I'm not sure how nuanced it gets yet as I've not run it through very many scenarios. It is not clear to me if it is up on variants or if it just uses the most popular variant (highest selling) for a given model.

    I'll be sure to be investigating it more.
    02-17-2015 02:45 PM
  8. RumoredNow's Avatar
    Here is a great global reference sheet that is a quick and easy lookup tool for those who understand frequencies in shorthand form.
    GSM World Coverage Map- GSM Country List by frequency bands

    Also added to post #2; lists of reference links
    04-12-2015 12:49 AM

Similar Threads

  1. How to get my blog post published to Windowscentral?
    By Windows Central Question in forum Ask a Question
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 12-05-2014, 06:10 PM
  2. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-05-2014, 05:54 PM
  3. Video shows off early version of Cortana running on Windows 10
    By WindowsCentral.com in forum Windows Central News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 12-05-2014, 03:42 PM
  4. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 12-05-2014, 03:03 PM
  5. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 12-05-2014, 02:39 PM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD