1. Al Sacco's Avatar
    So I've had my 15-inch Surface Book 2 for more than a week now, and I've been working on it, along with two monitors connected via Surface Dock, every day. Overall, I'm very pleased with the purchase. I love the keyboard and trackpad when working away from my desk, battery life has been great, and performance has been buttery-smooth. The only things that I don't love about it (though I also wouldn't say I hate them) are the size and weight. I traveled with it last weekend, and it felt a like big flat rock in my bag. I'm coming from the Surface Pro, so part of that is just my perspective, I know. But I also use a MacBook Pro 15-inch on occasion (gasp!), and though the SB2 is only about 0.2 pounds heavier, it's significantly thicker. I'm not really complaining, and I know the form factor necessitates the larger size to an extent, but that's really the only complaint I have so far.

    Do you have a new Surface Book 2? What do you love/like or hate/dislike about it?
    11-30-2017 08:58 AM
  2. Garcessist's Avatar
    I just got my SB2 15inch after returning the SB2 13.5 inch. I love my 15 inch I just wish they had done everything on the 15 inch in the 13.5 inch. IE CPU cooling in the tablet portion and the GTX1060.
    Joe920 likes this.
    11-30-2017 01:39 PM
  3. petvas72's Avatar
    I have my 13,5" SB2 since last week and I am loving it. Compared to my Surface Book first generation, this is a better product. It feels sturdier, more stable and even faster. It is a joy to use it. I hope it will not have any reliability issues like the Surface Book of the first generation.
    Battery life seems good, better than the 1st gen, but I still cannot really judge. Definitely an improvement overall and I am loving my Surface Book 2.
    12-03-2017 04:44 PM
  4. podsnap's Avatar
    I absolutely love the hardware and I know it's divisive but the hinge is so cool and I think it makes the design iconic.

    Haven't done any really long test yet but the battery life for me seems disappointing. When using Sketchable with just the screen the battery percentage ticks down at an alarming rate (I'd estimate about 2 hours of drawing time).

    Also, while most of the time I don't notice, the coil whine is irritating when you do hear it.

    Oh, the weight and balance of the screen on it's own is astonishingly good.
    Last edited by podsnap; 12-06-2017 at 11:16 AM.
    12-06-2017 11:05 AM
  5. petvas72's Avatar
    My Surface Book does not display a battery life estimate. Is this happening to others too?
    12-06-2017 04:05 PM
  6. podsnap's Avatar
    Yeah, mine doesn't show battery life estimate either but I'm pretty sure that's by design. Battery life estimates were never accurate (they never could be).
    12-07-2017 10:28 AM
  7. DCW1000's Avatar
    The thing I like best about the 15 inch Book 2 is that is basically a Studio Lite.

    I haven't yet found anything I don't like about it.

    I've had it about three weeks now.
    12-11-2017 10:58 AM
  8. Joe920's Avatar
    I just got my SB2 15inch after returning the SB2 13.5 inch. I love my 15 inch I just wish they had done everything on the 15 inch in the 13.5 inch. IE CPU cooling in the tablet portion and the GTX1060.
    Exactly. I don't have a SB2 (hope I'm allowed to post here!), but I have played with both the 13.5" and 15" in the store, and while I'm in love with the 15" screen, I much prefer the lower weight of the 13.5". This makes for a difficult choice: get a compact system with a GTX 1050, or get a behemoth with a GTX 1060.. Result: I haven't bought either of them yet! Awesome devices though.
    12-11-2017 11:40 AM
  9. IdleMind's Avatar
    I have the 15" SB2 and so far I'm really enjoying it. No complaints. I did notice a slight issue with the mouse a few times where the mouse pointer appeared to drift after I stopped scrolling.
    12-11-2017 11:49 AM
  10. kodos78's Avatar
    I have a 13.5" 1TB right now, and have a 15" 1TB on its way. I was torn between which one to get, so I'm going to try both and return the one that I dislike more.

    So far I really love the 13.5" model. It is snappy, does everything I need really well and is pretty portable. I have an ultrabook (Surface Laptop) that I take when I need to write documents -- but for heavy duty coding and productivity stuff, the SB2 is far better.

    I like that I can read with the tablet detached. I love browsing the web in tablet mode. I also like the clipboard functionality when I am doing teaching with the kids (we homeschool our children) or have to sketch out a quick presentation.

    Love that I don't hear fans. I don't use the GPU for much (not a gamer) other than video encoding so I have yet to hear the GPU do anything.

    I have had coil whine with this unit though. Dislike. It isn't too bad though and sounds like an old style platter drive churning away. Not "whiny" and high pitched.

    So far, been great!
    Saeglopur89 and Joe920 like this.
    12-11-2017 11:49 AM
  11. TabletWriter's Avatar
    I was hoping that with the second generation they'd do two things: Add a kickstand and make a SP keyboard available as an option. That way, when travelling you could leave the heavy base at home and clip on a Alcantara keyboard and basically have two computers in one. I know, that would add another $200 to the price, but I think it would be a hit.
    threezit and Joe920 like this.
    12-11-2017 02:21 PM
  12. garak0410's Avatar
    I'm am really considering selling my Gen 1 SB but trying to decide if I want the 15" with 256GB and better GPU or the 13.5 with 512GB and lessor GPU. With "placeholders" back on OneDrive, I might be able to live without the extra storage.
    12-11-2017 02:22 PM
  13. ndawghoodstar's Avatar
    I have the 15” 512.
    I love it.
    But I HATE that tilt support doesn’t work. It just doesn’t and I can’t figure it out.
    Huge upgrade though from the original surface rt
    12-11-2017 03:25 PM
  14. petvas72's Avatar
    I'm am really considering selling my Gen 1 SB but trying to decide if I want the 15" with 256GB and better GPU or the 13.5 with 512GB and lessor GPU. With "placeholders" back on OneDrive, I might be able to live without the extra storage.
    In Germany we don't have the 15" option, but I would go with more storage and RAM.I have the 512GB model and some times I feel I should have gotten the 1TB model.
    garak0410 likes this.
    12-11-2017 04:38 PM
  15. Ferenc Toth's Avatar
    I was hoping that with the second generation they'd do two things: Add a kickstand and make a SP keyboard available as an option. That way, when travelling you could leave the heavy base at home and clip on a Alcantara keyboard and basically have two computers in one. I know, that would add another $200 to the price, but I think it would be a hit.
    I was hoping for at least a hint of a move towards a some kind of modular system where you could use the tablet as standalone, and add a performance base, or just typecover, as you see fit for your self. Take the performance base with you when you need more battery and power, and the typecover when you want to travel light.
    Joe920 and Feralboy like this.
    12-11-2017 07:25 PM
  16. garak0410's Avatar
    In Germany we don't have the 15" option, but I would go with more storage and RAM.I have the 512GB model and some times I feel I should have gotten the 1TB model.
    True...I believe the 2GB of memory on the GeForce 1050 may be enough for me as I don't game on the go often but it is nice to have.
    12-11-2017 08:03 PM
  17. mweflen's Avatar
    I've had the 15" for about two weeks now. I got it from the Amazon Vine program to review. It's definitely the best laptop I've ever owned. It's really amped up my creativity and I draw for hours daily with it. It's powerful enough for AAA gaming. (which I don't really do due to storage)

    That's not to say it's perfect, though.

    -I don't like how the GPU spins up on certain web browsing tasks. For some reason, when downloading files in Opera, the GPU is activated and the fans spin pretty loudly. This is unusual because the fans generally are silent and do a great job of cooling.

    -I find the Surface Pen difficult not to grip tightly, which ends up straining my hand after drawing for a few hours. I'm ordering some jelly pencil holders to try and ameliorate this.

    -I think 256gb of storage for $2500 is insane. It should have shipped with 512gb minimum.

    -It doesn't have a control key on the right side of the keyboard. It also inverts the function keys with the shortcuts - I generally use F2 quite a bit to rename files, and now I have to press Fn-F2. Speaking of the function keys, it doesn't have a dedicated key for turning off the display.
    Joe920 likes this.
    12-12-2017 01:47 AM
  18. HarnessTech's Avatar
    My biggest complaint at the moment is in regards to the Surface Dock. The whole thing is just not stable. The external monitor flickers during boot and it briefly goes off when connecting or disconnecting USB peripherals (and I've tried 3 different DisplayPort cables). Sometimes the monitor just goes off for about 3 seconds randomly for no reason. However, I suspect this is more about the Surface Dock than it is the SB2.

    My #2 complaint is picking up the SB2 when closed to put it in or take it out of my laptop bag. I'm afraid to squeeze it too tight and it's slippery. I feel like it needs some kind of grippy pads or something attached to it or something. Maybe I'm just too paranoid about squeezing it, but I always tend to baby my tech equipment, especially when it is expensive and I expect it to last for several years.
    12-12-2017 11:27 AM
  19. Joel DSO's Avatar
    -It doesn't have a control key on the right side of the keyboard. It also inverts the function keys with the shortcuts - I generally use F2 quite a bit to rename files, and now I have to press Fn-F2. Speaking of the function keys, it doesn't have a dedicated key for turning off the display.
    just a quick tip, for surface devices there is a shortcut to change how the function keys work: pressing Fn and Caps lock changes the primary function between F keys and function keys.
    mweflen likes this.
    12-12-2017 11:37 AM
  20. ZipZapRap's Avatar
    So I've had my 15-inch Surface Book 2 for more than a week now, and I've been working on it, along with two monitors connected via Surface Dock, every day. Overall, I'm very pleased with the purchase. I love the keyboard and trackpad when working away from my desk, battery life has been great, and performance has been buttery-smooth. The only things that I don't love about it (though I also wouldn't say I hate them) are the size and weight. I traveled with it last weekend, and it felt a like big flat rock in my bag. I'm coming from the Surface Pro, so part of that is just my perspective, I know. But I also use a MacBook Pro 15-inch on occasion (gasp!), and though the SB2 is only about 0.2 pounds heavier, it's significantly thicker. I'm not really complaining, and I know the form factor necessitates the larger size to an extent, but that's really the only complaint I have so far.

    Do you have a new Surface Book 2? What do you love/like or hate/dislike about it?
    I wish we had the 15" here in Australia. I ended up getting the 13" instead. A brilliant device and I'm actually happy there's no fan in the tablet, that's a bonus over the 15"

    I love this thing, and I'm yet to find something I dislike about it.
    12-12-2017 04:03 PM
  21. garak0410's Avatar
    I've had the 15" for about two weeks now. I got it from the Amazon Vine program to review. It's definitely the best laptop I've ever owned. It's really amped up my creativity and I draw for hours daily with it. It's powerful enough for AAA gaming. (which I don't really do due to storage)

    That's not to say it's perfect, though.

    -I don't like how the GPU spins up on certain web browsing tasks. For some reason, when downloading files in Opera, the GPU is activated and the fans spin pretty loudly. This is unusual because the fans generally are silent and do a great job of cooling.

    -I find the Surface Pen difficult not to grip tightly, which ends up straining my hand after drawing for a few hours. I'm ordering some jelly pencil holders to try and ameliorate this.

    -I think 256gb of storage for $2500 is insane. It should have shipped with 512gb minimum.

    -It doesn't have a control key on the right side of the keyboard. It also inverts the function keys with the shortcuts - I generally use F2 quite a bit to rename files, and now I have to press Fn-F2. Speaking of the function keys, it doesn't have a dedicated key for turning off the display.
    I'm a Vine reviewer as well. Their algorithms for what they give you to choose from to review are quite interesting. I have nothing but bra's and socks right now but may end up with a cool tech device the next day.
    mweflen likes this.
    12-12-2017 04:41 PM
  22. mweflen's Avatar
    I'm a Vine reviewer as well. Their algorithms for what they give you to choose from to review are quite interesting. I have nothing but bra's and socks right now but may end up with a cool tech device the next day.
    And a DS9 fan?

    I can't pretend to know how the algorithm works, but I will say, when I see something in a "high value" category like laptops or phones, I will grab it, and in my experience, that leads to being offered more of the same in the future. Case in point: the half dozen projectors I've reviewed, three laptops now, and two phones.
    12-12-2017 09:52 PM
  23. garak0410's Avatar
    And a DS9 fan?

    I can't pretend to know how the algorithm works, but I will say, when I see something in a "high value" category like laptops or phones, I will grab it, and in my experience, that leads to being offered more of the same in the future. Case in point: the half dozen projectors I've reviewed, three laptops now, and two phones.
    Yep...love DS9 and Babylon 5 even more.

    Not to derail this thread, but yeah, it is odd on the things I get offered. The last laptops I got to review were an AlienWare and an Acer Alpha Switch 12 and that's been it the past 2-3 years. Just so weird.

    I am really trying to decide of the Surface Book with the 1050 or the 1060. Screen size isn't as important as storage but I believe I could live with the 256 now that OneDrive Placeholders are back.
    12-13-2017 09:14 AM
  24. mweflen's Avatar
    Yep...love DS9 and Babylon 5 even more.

    Not to derail this thread, but yeah, it is odd on the things I get offered. The last laptops I got to review were an AlienWare and an Acer Alpha Switch 12 and that's been it the past 2-3 years. Just so weird.

    I am really trying to decide of the Surface Book with the 1050 or the 1060. Screen size isn't as important as storage but I believe I could live with the 256 now that OneDrive Placeholders are back.
    I got the Acer Switch Alpha 12, too! Love it. My other laptop was an Acer Predator Helios 300. Like it.

    I'd say go for the 15". From a power standpoint (e.g. the 1060 and the 8th gen Core i7), it's much more future proof.
    12-13-2017 02:29 PM

Similar Threads

  1. Buying music vs. streaming: what you need to know
    By WindowsCentral.com in forum Windows Central News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-30-2017, 08:10 AM
  2. Surface book 2 15inch poor SSD speeds
    By Windows Central Question in forum Ask a Question
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-29-2017, 09:12 PM
  3. New drive-by cryptocurrency mining scheme persists after you exit your browser window
    By WindowsCentral.com in forum Windows Central News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-29-2017, 08:00 PM
  4. Here are the updates and changes coming to Destiny 2's end-game systems
    By WindowsCentral.com in forum Windows Central News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-29-2017, 07:20 PM
  5. Final Fantasy XV will soon let you swap characters on the fly
    By WindowsCentral.com in forum Windows Central News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11-29-2017, 04:50 PM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD