Amzer Smoke Argyle case
I bought the Amzer Smoke Argyle case on Amazon for $10. It's a sold, flexible, but stable plastic case (TPU) that covers all edges of the case. It's apparently similar to the infamous Body Glove case, but yet doesn't suck. It does cover the buttons, but it isn't so tight that it causes misfires. Pressing the buttons requires a little extra effort, but it is insurance against pocket photos and busting your eardrums. Also, there are bumps over the buttons so you can feel them by running your finger up the sides.
It fits the phone very well and there is no chance of it coming off in your pocket or bag. The TPU gives the phone a grip so it's a lot easier to hold on to. Without the case, I was always afraid of dropping the phone or it slipping out of my hands. Now, I'm not. The case adds... maybe a millimeter to all dimensions of the phone, so it doesn't bulk the phone up unreasonably. In fact, I've found that the extra thickness also helps make the phone easier to hold onto. Before, it was just... too thin.
Finally,the design. It's a translucent gray except for the frosted argyle pattern. It can either be tacky or great, depending upon your perspective. I like it, I think it looks classy.
Finally, my one complaint, which is actually a backhanded compliment. There's a little ridge (like 1mm high) that runs around the outside of the phone and holds the screen off a table when you set it down face down. Well, it digs into my ear when I'm calling people. Honestly, not too big a deal. The speaker is loud enough that I shouldn't be trying to install my phone IN the side of my face.
It's a great case. Buy it.
That's about