Comparing the Nokia Lumia with the BB10

[fbloise]

Just made a quick video comparing my Lumia 920 with the BB10. Do you guys think this BB10 has any chance against WP8 and the other major mobile OS?

Comparing the Nokia Lumia 920 and the Blackberry 10 - YouTube

 

[a5cent]

Thanks for the video, although I do think a lot could be improved.

Not systematic enough.

You are too often just stating what you prefer, instead of making it obvious why you prefer one over another.

If you demonstrate a feature on one device, you should also demonstrate it on the other, or it is not a comparison (Notifications).

You compared bb's app list (grid of icons) to wp's live tiles. I think a fairer comparison would need to introduce more of bb's UI.

The Lumia's screen was far too bright and often outside the area your video recorder had in focus. That made the Lumia's screen look pretty awful.

 

[jaj324]

Apparently a5cent isn't going to vote for u in the best picture award.
Sent from my AT&T 8x using Board Express

 

[a5cent]

Apparently a5cent isn't going to vote for u in the best picture award.

I'd vote for him before I voted for myself. He at least got off his a55 and made a video! ;-)

Is intended as constructive criticism.

 

[dkp23]

I think the gestures on bb10 going to be confusing. I read you have to slide up and then right or left or something to get to the hub? The whole OS is gesture based kind of like webos? That is not going to be fun.

 

[FinancialP]

It's really only two gestures. nothing confusing about that. The iPad has three, and no one is complaining.

 

[fbloise]

thanks, will take it in consideration for my next video. Appreciate the constructive criticism

 

[Tafsern]

Looking at the BB, I am really glad I picked Lumia 920. Looks unappealing.

 

[jaj324]

If that was constructive criticism I'd hate to see your regular criticism.

I'd vote for him before I voted for myself. He at least got off his a55 and made a video! ;-)

Is intended as constructive criticism.

Sent from my AT&T 8x using Board Express

 

[a5cent]

If that was constructive criticism I'd hate to see your regular criticism.

lol, yes, you would. We don't beat around the bush in my corner of the world :smile: