You started 2 threads with no substance, no personal opinion. Each of these threads is simply asking others to comment on a topic. There are already plenty of threads on this topic and people are giving their opinions in them.
Please don't start 2 threads when one would do (both of yours are on the same subject). Please don't start threads when there are already plenty of others with the same basic question and those threads are well established and easy to find... There are reasons that creating duplicate threads is not a good idea: it scatters the answers/opinions all around and makes the conversation hard to follow, it also forces other threads off the front page of the subforum and valuable help/urgent questions/interesting topics disappear from view before their time.