I really like everything but the background, I should keep that black :wink:
that's the magical point. People have different visions and we really dint know what MS will do down the line. Choice is good (I wouldn't use a background, but I like the overall menu and notifications).Nice try but it's way too cluttered and bad designed. I don't understand why people want to destroy windows phone with these full featured and cluttered UIs. Even stock android is cleaner than this concept. Windows phone is all about simplicity and this concept is full of detail that doesn't fit in small screen sizes.
The only good thing about this concept is the settings page but even that is questionable. The other parts of the UI are atrocious.
that's the magical point. People have different visions and we really dint know what MS will do down the line. Choice is good (I wouldn't use a background, but I like the overall menu and notifications).
To your point, I'm pretty sure apple and good looks at our OS and say "why would anyone buy that bland OS) because as much as I like WP, our OS is seriously bland, with the exception of live tiles.
for every good there is a bad. This is how the world works. I can keep arguing my point...Any OS will start to feel bland if you don't make changes to it. Changing a wallpaper is a good way to make it feel like new. Since windows phone doesn't have this ability, the way you make it feel new is by re-ordering your live tiles, changing the accent color and background color. I do it when it become stale to my taste and it feel like new every time. The live tiles is what makes windows phone less bland and that you don't get on any other OS.
The only way windows phone is going to have wallpaper support is by dimming the wallpaper itself like it's done in Windows 8 and not how this guy designed. It ruins the contrast of the tiles. It's bad design. It's not user-friendly.
The notification/toggles panel is the worst. He tried to fit every button and feature possible but later he found out that it failed miserably so he reduced the whole image to fit in the phone screen making every UI element so tiny that you almost can't read or press with your finger.
The settings app is actually good and usable but categorizing settings sometimes lead to worse user experience because if may be harder to find the things you're looking for. The search button he added might help with that.
He also should not use the Microsoft logo in his concepts. That's bad taste and copyright violation because makes it looking like it was Microsoft that designed or endorsed it.
This is why Microsoft and other companies shouldn't always listen to their user-base.
Nice try but it's way too cluttered and bad designed. I don't understand why people want to destroy windows phone with these full featured and cluttered UIs. Even stock android is cleaner than this concept. Windows phone is all about simplicity and this concept is full of detail that doesn't fit in small screen sizes.
The only good thing about this concept is the settings page but even that is questionable. The other parts of the UI are atrocious.
What you called waste was a conscious design decision by Microsoft to make pages less dense. This battle is one that early adopters and late-comers to WP have often (search for complaints about the blank area atop the first row of tiles on the Start screen, large headers for panoramas and pivots, etc)....I find that my design doesn't waste as much space at the top of the screen...