- 07-02-2013, 02:34 AM #1
I guess a little bit of back story is on order here.
First of all, I have stuck my guns with windows phone for as long as I remember. It started with the Samsung Omnia 7, and so began my love affair with the whole interface. Soon, I made the jump to a Lumia 800. I couldn't take my eyes off that beautiful phone, and because I had bought my Samsung outright, I just sold it off and got the Lumia on contract (I was in Australia then). I can safely say that I have seen the growing rise of windows phone, and like many others in this community, spread the word around. In Jan of this year, I moved to India, my home, right around the time when the Lumia 920 was going to be launched. Fresh of the boat and with a really good exchange rate for my AUD, I had no trouble purchasing a white shiny Lumia 920 (outright, India has no contract plans) as soon as it came out. I was, and still am working with a company which makes Android ROM's, and Launchers, and even though there was an existing company policy of paying half the money for an Android handset, if an employee happens to buy one, I decided to buy the 920 out of my own pocket.
I knew I would love it, and I was not disappointed.
Throughout all these days I managed to turn my wife, my cousin brother and his wife, my sister and quite a few friend to see the charms of the WP8 OS. The latest addition to the family was a Lumia 720 a month ago, courtesy my dad.
Coming to the issue now, this happened a month back. I was cycling back from work when it started raining. I took my phone out of the pocket and put it inside a plastic cover, which then went inside my backpack. After getting home and opening the bag though, I saw that water had still managed to seep in. My first impulse was to check the laptop, which was working fine, and the next, my 920, which was not. It was not switching on, but randomly switched on after sometime, and the touch was not registering. So next day i took it to the Nokia Service Centre, and after opening the chassis and going through its internals, they said that it was water damaged and that they will fix it but it will cost me Rs. 15,000. For a comparison, I had bought the handset for Rs 37,000. I was shocked at the price, but still decided to get it done. My adoration for the phone really overtook my common sense there. I was told they will return the phone to me within two days.
After 2 days I get a call from the centre, saying that they were not able to repair it out at the service centre, and therefore will be sending it out to the head factory, and therefore wait for 2 weeks. I said fine, let us do that. In all this while, I was basically without a smartphone (my job really requires me to be connected at all times). Any which way, after waiting for more than two weeks and calling them repeatedly after the said period was over, they finally returned the phone to me today. The Rep looked me in the eye, and told me the handset cant be repaired. I asked her twice, and both times I got the same reply. That the handset cannot be repaired. I am attaching a pic of the phone as they returned it to me.
Right now I am angry. I really am. I paid for this phone, a phone I loved from a company I have supported and spread good word about, but its shocking to see how cavalier its support is in a country (which might be a developing nation to many people), but is still one of its last major strongholds when it comes to marketshare. Today Nokia lost on of its most ardent supporters.
Currently I am at work, and have already spoken to the HR about procuring an Android based handset (I am thinking the HTC One) for which atleast they will pay me half the money. So yes, I don't think I will turn around and come back to Windows Phone anytime sooner.
I also understand that a lot of people will tell me that I should not treat the WP for what Nokia has done to me, but really, deep inside, we all know that Nokia is synonymous with WP. HTC and Samsung are just not in the same league. And if for nothing else, I don't have enough money or patience to buy another flagship handset outright and get dissed by the company when it comes to servicing.
Finally, I want to word my thoughts to someone at a senior level, possibly Stephen Elop. Isn't he supposed to be answering all his emails nowadays according to a lot of Windows Phone sites? Lets see what he has to say to my problem.
Last edited by Desdemona; 07-02-2013 at 02:36 AM. Reason: Require Email ID
07-02-2013, 02:46 AM #2
- 2,777 Posts
Hate to say this but. Rookie mistake getting it sent off for water damage.
My girlfriend dropped her 920 in a toilet. Surprisingly it didn't work when she went to use it - but I got her to stick it in a ziplock bag with some rice and told her to leave it for 24 hours. Works fine to this day.
07-02-2013, 03:24 AM #4
- 348 Posts
Since you seem to have decided to go to an Android handset, I recommend a Sony Experia Z, since that has a water resistant treatment. An HTC One will suffer water damage in the same way as your Lumia 920.
As a cyclist and an Englishman, I'm no stranger to rain, but I'm afraid I can't agree that Nokia have done anything wrong. People have claimed the 920 is a rugged phone in terms of knocks and scrapes, but no claim of water resistance has ever been made, so it's up to you to take adequate care of your device.
In my experience, the best thing to do when a device gets wet is switch it off immediately, take the battery out if you can and then leave the device to dry off naturally. Either with some rice or silica gel to absorb the moisture, or in an airing cupboard. These methods only work about 50% of the time however.
I wear my 920 in a belt holder, which is enough to hold off light showers, but in heavy rain the 920 is protected under my coat or if I'm going to work in a water-proof rucksack.
Given you situation, I see no reason apart from the subsidy to prefer an HTC One over a replacement Nokia, be it a 920 or 925.
- 07-02-2013, 03:27 AM #5
What a bad experience! I'm shocked. If I was in your position I would be angry too. But I think you do have a way out.
First of all I can understand taking the phone to Nokia Care but I have never once seen any company try to repair a water dmaged phone, its always without wmquestion a replacement of the parts or entire phone, so I'm shocked they charged you for a repair. On the other hand with water damage you should always expect the manufacturer to put up resistance, even if 90% of the time its accidental. They have warranties which specifically say they don't cover water damage.
Its possible for you to insure your phone for a small fee per month and after a week or two you can tell them what originally happened and they will most likely replace it. You would have to make sure the insurance covered water damage though.
Alternatively, you could try emailing Mr. Elop as you say and telling him about the situation. In the past some people have had success in getting replacement phones or whatever their problem was, sorted.
Its sad to see something like this happen, especially to someone that likes WP so much, but try to bear in mind that regardless of Nokia and WP I know lots of people throughout basically all of the manufacturers that have had a similar experience. That, at least,is something you can expect from most manufacturers when it comes to water damage.
- 07-02-2013, 05:17 AM #8
- 07-02-2013, 05:33 AM #9
- 07-02-2013, 05:35 AM #10
Another user unfairly blaming a phone manufacturer for their own mistake. Good luck finding a company that could have done any better for you.
How is Nokia supposed to know if it is beyond repair before sending it in? Did they keep your money? I fail to see how they have wronged you in any way. Quite the contrary.
If you think HTC would have had some type of magic fix for you you're sadly mistaken. Take care of your phone dude. And when you screw up, put your big boy pants on and don't misdirect your blame. Don't blame a corporation for following the normal repair process and finding that it was unsalvageable.
07-02-2013, 06:09 AM #13
- 129 Posts
Sorry OP, I don't know if Nokia had to pay for your mistakes. Every device manufacturer specifically mentions that they don't cover any type of liquid damage. When you said you had invested so much money, you should have brought a phone insurance. Clearly, it is your mistake of not taking proper precaution in handling your phone. Today you said its only water damage. Tomorrow someone would claim that Nokia didn't replace their broken screen.... Wait a sec, Nokia never mentioned that they would give you life time warranty for your mishandling of phone. Did they?
Fixing minor things like Volume rocker and all are definitely taken care by any manufacturer. I had it happen to my Lumia 800 in the past and they did honor by replacing the volume rocker.
- 07-02-2013, 06:12 AM #14
You may write to Elop if you want, but seriously, no matter how tough it is to admit, the phone was screwed by you (albeit accidentally).
I know how you feel because you paid a lot of money for that phone but, well let's just call it tough luck. Nokia would have fixed/replaced the phone if the damage occurred was covered under warranty. I have had two Lumias in the past (800 and 710). Call it coincidence, they both died after a few weeks of purchase. I took them to Nokia Care and they apologetically replace both of them.
No one can stop you from switching but at least don't blame Nokia for this. Maybe it really was beyond repair by them. If you want you can checkout a few tear-down guides on the internet to see if you can figure out what went wrong.
And yeah, one last thing. If you have so like Windows Phone as you say, you will never be comfortable with Android now :)
07-02-2013, 06:29 AM #17
- 168 Posts
Sorry to hear that. I wonder if part of it would be the lack of removeable battery? I have an HTC Titan that ended up in a swimming pool with me, about five feet down and obviously not just water that "seeped" in ;). I took the phone's back cover off, removed the battery and SIM card and placed it in rice; two days later it was powering on. I can still see hints of moisture trapped around the edges of the screen but almost one year later and it's still working like brand new. And while it's too late for you to try this, I was told if this happens, *don't* power on the phone. Immediately disassemble what you can and stick it in rice or another desiccant. I'm hoping there's an Otterbox or similar option available when the EOS is released to replace my Titan - Techiedude
07-02-2013, 07:19 AM #18
- 128 Posts
Listen I sympathize with you for your bad experience but on this particular occasion you cannot blame the company nor their customer care. I would chalk this up to bad luck and get on with my life.
Edit: FYI, I am Indian too. :)
Edit 2: Read this.
Lumia survival story: from 5-minute lake dive to a fully working phone
- 07-02-2013, 08:10 AM #20
I should also tell you that I am very sorry for the loss of your phone. I know I would feel awful, and I know waiting over two weeks to find out it was not repairable didn't help those feelings.
But please don't let your feelings unfairly color your perception of Nokia or Windows Phone. I'm telling you, this situation would not have been handled any better by another manufacturer, unless you got very lucky and were the recipient of someone's pity and they replaced it. Been known to happen, but it's not fair to expect it.
- 07-02-2013, 09:03 AM #23
The worst part of this is how much you like WP. Once you enjoy an OS, others will only remind you of what you had. I have had BlackBerry, WebOS, and now WP. I was okay with BlackBerry, but do not miss it. I love WP. But to this very day, I am reminded of what I miss about WebOS, and how much I enjoyed the way that phone worked. I get the feeling if you go Android, you will be fine, but you will miss things about WP. My wife had to move from WP to Android for business reasons. This has been a little over a month, and I am starting to hear "I miss....." quite often.
I urge you to write Mr. Elop as well. You are out nothing but the time it takes to type out an email. There is nothing wrong with Android. But, it isn't WP. And for those of us who love the OS, why settle? You live with these devices all day. It is worth the try.
Also, I see nothing wrong with how you handled this. Not sure why some people are suggesting you are not taking responsibility when it is obvious you are. You were promised a service from your local Nokia repair center, and they failed. Nothing wrong with being upset when they did not live up to what they promised in exchange for payment.
Nothing else, we will blame it on the rain. (Dated reference, bad pun alert.)
- 07-02-2013, 09:16 AM #24
This is all on you, man. Stop with the pity party. Stuff happens, deal with it.
Blame Nokia for your mistakes and then go on some silly rant about how you're leaving the OPERATING SYSTEM because of your misconceived notion that it's Nokia's fault that your phone suffered irreparable water damage. Completely irrational.
- 07-02-2013, 09:40 AM #25
"I drove my car in a lake, they tried to fix it, but are having a hard time. I hate their customer service."
Sounds silly when you break it down. I know you really liked your phone and I know how disappointed I would be not to have my L928 after having it for a bit now. I'm sure there is some kind of insurance support for electronic devices in India, not having it was your issue and getting it wet was your issue. You are mad you broke your phone, that they tried to fix it, and could not. That is the risk you take when you carry around a mini computer all the time. It really doesn't sound like a service issue to me, they are doing their best to fix a phone you bricked.
If they can't fix it, then the worst case is you ask for your service fee back for services not rendered.
- By JohnStrk in forum Windows Phone 8Replies: 3Last Post: 08-26-2013, 10:54 AM
- By driver_king in forum Windows Phone GamesReplies: 6Last Post: 07-23-2013, 04:43 PM
- By david90531 in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 8Last Post: 07-03-2013, 12:05 PM
- By Dadstar0410 in forum Microsoft Surface for Windows RTReplies: 4Last Post: 07-03-2013, 07:58 AM
- By Andy Dunn in forum Nokia Lumia 920Replies: 4Last Post: 07-03-2013, 12:17 AM