Somewhat satisfied. I still think, in retrospect, the Lumia 920 was the best phone I could have gotten at the time (and a few months later, the HTC One would have made that a much tougher decision). Unfortunately, while there's a lot to like about WP8, some things are just maddening.
It's odd that you say toast notifications are one of the highlights for you, because they are one of the most maddening shortcomings for me. Both my nexus 7 and my work iphone make it extremely easy to see a list of missed notifications, whereas my 920 falls short. On top of the lack of a notification history, the app gap means that some apps trail so far behind ios/android that they have no notifications, if they're there at all. Other apps seemingly have no connection between toast, tile, and app data.
I also find a big lack of cohesiveness in apps. For example, on both ios and android, if i open a link to something like instagram or zillow, it will ask if I want the app or the site, but WP8 only gives me the site. It seems like a lot more WP apps dump you into the full site for things that are included in the ios/android apps.
When they work, tiles blow away android widgets (and apple's abject refusal to allow dynamic info), and a few of the best make up for the lack of a notification center, but for the most part the 30 minute delays and lack of quality apps/tiles makes it hard to see that as a selling point.
The keyboard is better than iphone, but not as good as android's speedy swype. I'm really hoping that upgrade in 8.1, along with a fix of the broken notification/tile system, and Cortana are good enough to stick with windows phone