My observations of the ATIV S after 6 weeks of ownership. These are MY observations and relate to ME; YMMV and all that. . .
Just stumbled across this thread and can't believe how churlish some of the criticisms are.
Cons
buttons -
Volume control is a good 1-1.5mm proud of the case on my Ativ S and I have no trouble locating it.Plenty of other phones are more flush, including Nokias and HTCs. If it was any more proud you'd be complaining it was too easy to operate accidentally. Oh, hang on...
buttons -
Firstly, the volume control is
lower down, not directly opposite, the power button. That means there is a space for the supporting digit on the top left hand side of the phone. When holding in my left hand my thumb naturally rests
above the volume control. When holding in my right hand, my index finger is also
above the volume control or resting on the back. Even if my thumb or finger slips it'll hit the top edge (volume up) not down. If you're pressing the volume down button then you must have strange shaped hands or just holding it wierd. Also side mounting the power button on a large screen phone is good ergonomics. It's just awkward for many people to reach to the top of the phone when the screen size is 5" or more.
headphone socket -
YMMV. Bottom placement may be preferable for trouser storage, but doesn't work so well for short or jacket pockets. I also prefer it to be on the top so I can use standard USB docks and desk stands without fouling the headphone socket.
no audio DSP -
Hardly a 'glaring' omission. Plenty of phones, including some WP Nokias, don't have 'tone' controls. Personally I like mike music as it is intended and not mashed up by some artificial DSP. 'Flat' audio from the Ativ, paired with decent headphones, works fine for me.
no offline navigation -
Can't have looked very hard as there are a number of off-line navigation apps available, including CoPIlot.
SD-card problems -
Not had any problem with my Transcend or Kingston Class 4 cards. The only cards I have ever have had problems with are Sandisk and that's not just on Samsungs.
Slippery! -
Not a con if you've solved it. Personally I don't like Zagg as after a while the edges get dirty or start peeling and it starts to look like your phone is wrapped in Sellotape. A couple of bucks on a gel or other case is another simple and cheap option and gives more protection.
Camera lense -
Agreed, the Note has the same problem. But slip on even the slimmest of cases and problem fixed. Or cut an old clear screen protector to fit over the lense, like you get with Martin Fields'.
Overall, I'll take the smaller, lighter, more expandable, removal and bigger-batteried, bigger screened, less fault-prone, better camera [1], and much cheaper (especially with recent price drops) Ativ please.
[1] Noting the soft daylight pictures, overly compressed artifacts and noise, unnatural color balance, and make night-looks-like-day gimmicks of the 920