"Hot mess" is an oversimplification of a very complex and nuanced device. The hardware is beautiful; a masterful design. Do some people miss NFC, Qi or a better camera? Sure; no doubt. But gen 1 is not meant to be a swiss army knife for the populace. Get it in the hands of die-hards, people who will use it, abuse it, put it through its proverbial paces. There are certainly issues with it on release day; some of which are being addressed by a Day One patch -and there will certainly be more patches to come. A lot of the issues I'm running into center around Android - not a big surprise. And Microsoft will need to listen, adjust and address them accordingly - especially if they don't want a "hot mess" of flame wars to continue to disparage their product. I can agree with a majority of the reviews out there right now, exa "It's great, but". Would I recommend this phone to everyone? No. What someone gets out of this phone is going to depend on their willingness to retrain their brain. It's not a marketing tagline or slogan to say that this device is a paradigm shift in mobile computing. To quote Yoda, "You must unlearn what you have learned". And for some, that will be the biggest challenge.