Samsung is definitely out of my list...Here's why..

[X0LARIUM]

For all those think Samsung products are Uber-cool and niche, they are nothing but cheap plastic, and cheap cheap plastic..., guess you can never emphasize enough CHEAP CHEAP...

Just check this video:
Samsung Ativ S hands-on - YouTube

And see 0:52 - 0:55.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZ1tgI5Xol4&feature=related

1:20 - 1:26


Says it all...

 

[Getintothegame]

My opinion of Samsung really was tarnished with the lawsuit that Apple put against them. Argue all you want, there was some outright copying of iOS' interface - like contacts, for example - and some of the Apple trademark designs, like the Galaxy Tab 10.1.

Just my opinion, I even owned an SIII for a bit.

 

[X0LARIUM]

My opinion of Samsung really was tarnished with the lawsuit that Apple put against them. Argue all you want, there was some outright copying of iOS' interface - like contacts, for example - and some of the Apple trademark designs, like the Galaxy Tab 10.1.

Just my opinion, I even owned an SIII for a bit.

Agree. I too could see some similarities.

 

[SnailUK]

Strangely i watched that video and thought exactly the same thing.

Combined with the iPhone 5 vs Galaxy S3 drop test video, shows the Samsung phones will definitely stand up to the abuse my kids give my phone.

 

[jabtano]

Maybe not if this comes to T-MO I would get the ATIVs over the L810 or the 8x.

 

[robinleck]

For all those think Samsung products are Uber-cool and niche, they are nothing but cheap plastic, and cheap cheap plastic..., guess you can never emphasize enough CHEAP CHEAP...

Just check this video:
Samsung Ativ S hands-on - YouTube

And see 0:52 - 0:55.


Samsung Ativ S hands on Windows8Phone Review Preview IFA 2012 - YouTube

1:20 - 1:26


Says it all...

+1
Totally concur with you, Samsung is shamelessly CHEAP!!!

 

[Coreldan]

Yeah, I think I got some shivers when he took off the back cover and was bending it.

And this, my friends, is why the Lumia 920 weighs 180g. It doesn't bend!

 

[X0LARIUM]

Yeah, I think I got some shivers when he took off the back cover and was bending it.

And this, my friends, is why the Lumia 920 weighs 180g. It doesn't bend!

yea..even I cringed a little...thought it might snap anytime...

 

[Winterfang]

All I see is a light, shiny, beautiful device.

 

[VagrantWade]

I work with multiple people who have the Galaxy S3. And it is the cheapest feeling phone I think I have ever felt in this decade. I would imagine it's why they have them stuffed in massive gaudy cases.

 

[jmshub]

To be honest, I don't care what the case is made of. If the case is at least sturdy enough to not destroy the screen the first time it falls from a desk, then I'm ok. Samsung builds attractively thin devices and, unless that 920 screen is uber impressive, the best screens on phones, period.

I am probably going with the 920, but the ativ could be a spoiler when I see that screen in person.

Sent from my SGH-i917 using Board Express

 

[tk-093]

I work with multiple people who have the Galaxy S3. And it is the cheapest feeling phone I think I have ever felt in this decade. I would imagine it's why they have them stuffed in massive gaudy cases.

I have a GS3 and I disagree.. It's light.. sure, but I don't think it feels overly cheap at all. Well, not worse then any other phone I've used.

 

[Winterfang]

Some people still had the old HTC mentality. That a heavier phone is somehow more sturdy.

 

[squire777]

plastic does not necessarily equal cheap. A bendable back plate probably means that it can take more of a beating and probably wouldn't crack if it were dropped on the back. I also have played around with a GS3 and never thought it was 'cheap' or 'flimsy'.

And the Apple lawsuit against Samsung would make me want to buy a Samsung device just to say 'up yours' to Apple.

 

[aubreyq]

I have a Samsung Focus and can relate to the "flimsy" back cover. There's a part that doesn't close well. Might have happened during a period where I wasn't using a case. Regardless, it's not the flimsy back cover that kills the ATIV S for me, it's the utterly boring, uninspired design that does.

 

[Heron_Kusanagi]

Samsung is out for me, not because of flimsy construction, but a distinct lack of support for WP8 at least.

I hope to be proven wrong completely, but I will rather cast my vote to Nokia or even HTC.

 

[brmiller1976]

Watching the Nokia bashing of Samsung is surreal. You are aware that those "polycarbonate" 920s are "cheap plastic" too, right?!?

 

[Jay Bennett]

It certainly seems like the Ativ is going to feel a little cheap on the outside, but let's not forget in many respects it has the highest specs of the WP8 line-up. It feels to me that Samsung piles all their investment into internals whilst others have been investing in the phone designs. Whilst that won't appeal to everyone, people looking for the absolute top specs for their cash will likely find the Ativ the perfect purchase

 

[Dr. Impossible]

Yeah, I think I got some shivers when he took off the back cover and was bending it.

And this, my friends, is why the Lumia 920 weighs 180g. It doesn't bend!

Wierd, I thought the same exact thing. Prior to seeing this, I thought the brushed aluminum of the Ativ was at least nice and had a refined look to it even though I thought the phone was pretty blah. But at that exact moment, when he took off the cover and bent it, was when I changed my mind and really thought that it was pretty cheap. Disappointment. I am using a Samsung 23 inch monitor right now for my desktop which I absolutely love, I've always loved their TV's and thought everything they made with a screen on it was gorgeous. My opinion is now changing.

Thanks

-Doc

 

[Dr. Impossible]

It certainly seems like the Ativ is going to feel a little cheap on the outside, but let's not forget in many respects it has the highest specs of the WP8 line-up. It feels to me that Samsung piles all their investment into internals whilst others have been investing in the phone designs. Whilst that won't appeal to everyone, people looking for the absolute top specs for their cash will likely find the Ativ the perfect purchase

Jay, I'm totally down with what you are saying, and I think you're right.

However.....

I think true inspired design combines both the form and the function, the other Manufacturers have been doing that and people are responding to it positively. I like seeing them go the extra length, and those other phones have some pretty nice specs to boot. It's what has me going back and forth between Nokia and HTC and not even considering the Ativ.

Thanks

-Doc