Suggest me a game?

[James Allan]

Okay so recently my interest in my 360 has seriously dwindled. I haven't turned it on in 2-3 months now. So I'm asking you guys to suggest me a game(s) that will re-kindle my interest. I enjoy ALL types of games. I have played a lot of the big games i.e fallout, skyrim, oblivion, GTA, mass effect etc etc.

I was thinking of picking up Terraria or Wolfenstein The New Order.

EDIT: I do not have Xbox Live